Run for your lives! The President is unpopular!
Take everything I wrote in the last two posts about the big picture and apply them to this story.
The Big Lie The Media’s Telling You About Obama’s Approval Rating
Happy cognitive empowerment :)
Monday, November 3, 2014
Another look at the Big Picture
In almost a perfect follow-up to my recent post on creating and examining the Big Picture, The Atlantic published this story by Norm Ornstein on the media narrative in this election season. When Conspiracy Theories Don't Fit the Media Narrative examines the maddening tendency of not just cable news, but our premier newspapers of record to report stories that conform to whatever theme for the election that surfaced arbitrarily along the way. This time around, The Washington Post and New York Times collectively determined that this season they would push the narrative that Republican establishment types have reclaimed the party for conventional nominees as opposed to wacko tea partiers. So things are just humming along nice and smoothly as the nomination process is back in the hands of campaign managers and national leaders, democracy be damned.
The subtle underpinnings that this whole concept is anti-democratic seems to be lost in the shuffle. As though the RNC and lavishly funded right wing operatives are saying "dear God, we can't let these people pick our nominees, they're friggin' crazy!" If we put aside for the moment that yes, they are, and so is your entire ideology it says to the objective observer that Republicans really do need to hide their real intentions in order to win office. Ornstein points out that the major newspapers, whose reporting and facts we are supposed to accept as honest, even true, are in fact dependent on someone else's preconceived narrative. Facts, like belief in conspiracy theories by these supposed establishment, civilized Republicans, that do not fit the frame are ignored. But boy do we here about the trivial gaffes from Democratic nominees.
So, does this critique undermine my recent support of big picture thinking? Am I hopelessly biased in favor of independent and occasionally dissident analysts like Thomas Frank or AlterNet? Maybe, but there is a crucial element missing in the narrative examined by Ornstein, empiricism. Generalizations that lead to narratives must first be drawn from actually existing evidence. Examining the primary sources, which unfortunately often includes newspaper articles that may or may not be suffering from the very cart-before-the horse thinking presented by Ornstein, is the first step in an historian's trade. Some evidence may support your hypothesis about the past, other evidence may not but it is the evidence that drives the narrative not the other way around.
Empiricism should be a self-evident basis for trying to understand who we are and where we come from but those two things are also based on the fact that we are human. And humans are erratic, unpredictable, and sometimes downright irrational. It takes years of training and experience to overcome these tendencies, and often more to locate the in others. Then there are problems of identifying agendas, which can be as benign as meeting a deadline or as insidious as deliberate deception of your audience to further some other goal. In the case Ornstein examines it is the former, time constraints or even simple laziness can lead a reporter to depend on what was written yesterday to inform his or her findings.
We hope that Ornstein is correct when he concludes:
The subtle underpinnings that this whole concept is anti-democratic seems to be lost in the shuffle. As though the RNC and lavishly funded right wing operatives are saying "dear God, we can't let these people pick our nominees, they're friggin' crazy!" If we put aside for the moment that yes, they are, and so is your entire ideology it says to the objective observer that Republicans really do need to hide their real intentions in order to win office. Ornstein points out that the major newspapers, whose reporting and facts we are supposed to accept as honest, even true, are in fact dependent on someone else's preconceived narrative. Facts, like belief in conspiracy theories by these supposed establishment, civilized Republicans, that do not fit the frame are ignored. But boy do we here about the trivial gaffes from Democratic nominees.
So, does this critique undermine my recent support of big picture thinking? Am I hopelessly biased in favor of independent and occasionally dissident analysts like Thomas Frank or AlterNet? Maybe, but there is a crucial element missing in the narrative examined by Ornstein, empiricism. Generalizations that lead to narratives must first be drawn from actually existing evidence. Examining the primary sources, which unfortunately often includes newspaper articles that may or may not be suffering from the very cart-before-the horse thinking presented by Ornstein, is the first step in an historian's trade. Some evidence may support your hypothesis about the past, other evidence may not but it is the evidence that drives the narrative not the other way around.
Empiricism should be a self-evident basis for trying to understand who we are and where we come from but those two things are also based on the fact that we are human. And humans are erratic, unpredictable, and sometimes downright irrational. It takes years of training and experience to overcome these tendencies, and often more to locate the in others. Then there are problems of identifying agendas, which can be as benign as meeting a deadline or as insidious as deliberate deception of your audience to further some other goal. In the case Ornstein examines it is the former, time constraints or even simple laziness can lead a reporter to depend on what was written yesterday to inform his or her findings.
We hope that Ornstein is correct when he concludes:
Of course, this does not mean that the press has a Republican bias, any more than it had an inherent Democratic bias in 2012 when Akin, Angle, and Mourdock led the coverage. What it suggests is how deeply the eagerness to pick a narrative and stick with it, and to resist stories that contradict the narrative, is embedded in the culture of campaign journalism. The alternative theory, that the Republican establishment won by surrendering its ground to its more ideologically extreme faction, picking candidates who are folksy and have great resumes but whose issue stances are much the same as their radical Tea Party rivals, goes mostly ignored. Meanwhile, there was plenty of coverage of the admittedly bonehead refusal by Kentucky Democratic Senate candidate Alison Lundergan [sic] Grimes to say she had voted for Obama—dozens of press references to NBC’s Chuck Todd saying it was “disqualifying”—but no stories saying that references to Agenda 21 or talking about terrorists and drug lords out to kill Arkansans were disqualifying.If you would like to read more about the latter effect of deliberate deception on our polarized political system, I would suggest Ornstein's book co-authored with Thomas Mann. It is a fairly objective look at how dysfunctional a government based on compromise and pragmatism becomes when extremism is the norm.
Sunday, November 2, 2014
"The GOP Mantra"
-Lincoln LogInteresting discussion in class. One student asserted that women should earn less than men. "What about equal pay for equal work?" "Well, if they *did* equal work, sure."
Same student did not like an increase in the minimum wage. "I'm working now at Walgreen's, busting my butt for minimum wage. But, I know that in the future I will be making a lot more."
All of this stemmed from a review of Hamilton's economic and political philosophy. Good opportunity to learn from student...s and encourage participation.
Then I had them look up the line from 1776 (on their magic telephones). "Don't forget that most men with nothing would rather protect the possibility of becoming rich than face the reality of being poor."
Wednesday, October 29, 2014
Frankly My Dear, We Are All Losers In This Apocalypse
One of an historian's greatest contributions to society has to be the ability to see the big picture. We start with oftentimes unrelated primary source documents and weave them into connecting prose. Like beads strung onto a string, these primary documents become more than the sum of their parts in historical analysis, revealing clues about the past to make a significant (sometimes even beautiful) picture about where we are. With enough empirical data, an historian can generalize about his or her subject. For instance, that food was a much higher proportion of a family's budget than rent in 1900 compared to 2000. The researcher, and/or others, makes use of the new data extrapolated from the primary sources to make further generalizations. If this process is repeated enough a narrative emerges, describing the world in a particular time and place. During election season it is very easy to get lost in individual races, issues, and events. To get at the big picture of American politics and society it is necessary to seek out narratives that ask the right questions. This essay compares two articles by authors asking those questions.
Thomas Frank is an historian whose works dig deep into the underbelly of American political life often agreeing with John Winger that we are mutants whose ancestors were kicked out of every civilized country on Earth, who thrive on getting over on each other at every social class level. If anyone can give a good narrative on the big picture it is Dr. Frank. His latest article in Salon, We are such losers is something of a reaction and tie-in to Rick Perlstein's latest big picture work The Invisible Bridge
, which will have to wait for it's own review from this blog. Frank uses the tool of historical comparison to make his larger point, that liberals fall in love with leaders who claim to be "post-partisan" and project their own values onto that leader. So the American left is continuously let down when those leaders turn out to not share their values. We are losers because we keep hoisting bland, well-meaning conservatives like Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton, and now Barack Obama into "great man" status and feel betrayed when they do not magically transform into liberal lions once in office. But liberals have always fallen in line behind standard bearers who not strong liberals, from Adlai Stevenson's day right down to presumably Hillary Clinton.
If one tried then to read patterns from Schlesinger's classic The Cycles of American History
onto the Carter years to today, you find almost a complete reversal. Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. argued with strong evidence a strong tendency of American politics to rotate from periods of reform to periods of conservatism where the public and institutions swallow the changes and the reformers are spent. While not usually thought of as a reformer, Richard Nixon did in fact bring about some sweeping changes. Notably the Environmental Protection Act that established the EPA and the Occupational Safety and Health Act were major domestic reforms that Nixon deserves at least some credit for enacting. But as Frank points out, Carter brought religion into the White House in a way it had not existed before, along with an almost authoritarian leadership style that saw social problems as simply a complex equation that when solved was also resolved. Popular belief is that deregulation began under Reagan but it was Carter that took the crucial first steps.
Since then, the cycles have been between periods of reactionary attacks on social programs and regressive tax cuts by Republicans, and efforts to close deficits and slow the cuts by Democrats. This reversal makes the supposed conservatives into reformers, much to the detriment of most Americans. And the supposed liberals into conservatives, putting much energy into simply preserving the New Deal. So what Frank points out in his article is that progressives are playing a losing game by backing "antipoliticians" like Carter and Obama. So if the only choices are conservatives and radical authoritarian reactionaries, what are actual liberals supposed to do?
Despair.
That is basically what Don Hazen, editor of AlterNet.org, argues in his look at the big picture.
s out there somewhere.
Is the big picture this bad? Can small victories or success in your personal life make these generalizations less meaningful? After all, these articles present the opinion of just two people, albeit smart and wise ones. How do reading these articles make you feel? Resentful? Angry? Inspired to prove them wrong? Or should you just brush the idea that there is anything wrong with the world off and go about your daily life without giving any more thought to the big picture?
It is, after all, up to you.
Thomas Frank is an historian whose works dig deep into the underbelly of American political life often agreeing with John Winger that we are mutants whose ancestors were kicked out of every civilized country on Earth, who thrive on getting over on each other at every social class level. If anyone can give a good narrative on the big picture it is Dr. Frank. His latest article in Salon, We are such losers is something of a reaction and tie-in to Rick Perlstein's latest big picture work The Invisible Bridge
If one tried then to read patterns from Schlesinger's classic The Cycles of American History
Since then, the cycles have been between periods of reactionary attacks on social programs and regressive tax cuts by Republicans, and efforts to close deficits and slow the cuts by Democrats. This reversal makes the supposed conservatives into reformers, much to the detriment of most Americans. And the supposed liberals into conservatives, putting much energy into simply preserving the New Deal. So what Frank points out in his article is that progressives are playing a losing game by backing "antipoliticians" like Carter and Obama. So if the only choices are conservatives and radical authoritarian reactionaries, what are actual liberals supposed to do?
Despair.
That is basically what Don Hazen, editor of AlterNet.org, argues in his look at the big picture.
Apocalypse Now: Seriously, It's Time for a Major Rethink About Liberal and Progressive Politics.
We are losing badly to the corporate state. Here's what we need to do.
Every day, [the entire range of horrendous and growing problems we face as a society and a planet] passes by before my eyes. At AlterNet, there are no issue silos—there is just the open faucet of depressing political information coming and going every hour of every day (with the occasional story of success and inspiration).
That is pretty gloomy, even to a GH. Hazen skewers much of the supposed liberal's conventional wisdom, that "if people just knew the truth they would vote for real change," and the insanity of continuing to do the same thing when it so rarely works. Elite, highly educated people control much of the apparatus of liberalism and progressivism in this country; people who do not feel the pain Republican budget cuts cause. Hazen does not state it openly, but this apparatus for reform has itself become conservative, with little imagination or new ideas.
So, the political system is blocked by out-of-touch conservatives while being wrecked by the opposition reactionaries, even reaching the political system is impossible due to the lobbyists guarding the gates. No money, no access. Meanwhile, the money that does come in for reform efforts is hopelessly diluted between single issue groups. Even the Democratic party is divided into so many parts, each chasing the same small pool of donations and often working at cross-purposes. Hazen also points out that many progressive thinkers believe in technology as a panacea, citing:
[M]y old friend Jerry Mander, formerly a guru at the Public Media Center in San Francisco. Mander is perhaps best known for his somewhat culty, much-loved 1978 anti-technology critique, 4 Arguments For the Elimination of Television. He made the case that problems with television are fundamental to the medium and the technology, and consequently cannot be reformed.Facebook and Google are not alternatives to the old-fashioned grind of organizing. Hazen reports that most progressives get their news from these giants, that we are at their mercy. I stand guilty of this as well, it is sad to say but talking to real people, in person, is very hard. But organizing is the only way out, making connections one-on-one, and building a real network instead of a virtual one. As I just said, I am as guilty as worst offender out there. I wish I possessed the social skills and courage to be an organizer. Those people exist right? They cannot all have been co-opted by the corporate world, using their skills simply to con people and make money. There have to be some Norma Rae
Is the big picture this bad? Can small victories or success in your personal life make these generalizations less meaningful? After all, these articles present the opinion of just two people, albeit smart and wise ones. How do reading these articles make you feel? Resentful? Angry? Inspired to prove them wrong? Or should you just brush the idea that there is anything wrong with the world off and go about your daily life without giving any more thought to the big picture?
It is, after all, up to you.
Friday, October 24, 2014
There Are No Ebola Zombies
Is the fact that people must actually state in plain language that Ebola will not and has not led to an epidemic of the undead shambling about a case of wishful thinking or plain stupidity? Look, we all love The Walking Dead
but isn't the whole zombie fad starting to lose a little steam?
Or is there truth when AlterNet asked, Are We That Gullible? No one really knows how far Ebola will get in the US or the extent of mutation in the virus, but it is just the slightest bit unlikely that casualties will be reanimated.
Before the current pop culture fascination with the living dead I had an idea to write a thriller about the zombie apocalypse occurring in the midst of complete governmental and societal dysfunction. But I never thought it would actually happen. Now we get to see how our eviscerated government, useless for-profit media, and large minority of completely insane and rabid 'wingers react to an outbreak of this dangerous disease. As much as I would like to believe Shepard Smith that we have absolutely nothing to fear, the truth is that the danger is not zero. Nor is it so great as to warrant the hysteria you see on the news.
Shep Smith is the guy Fox News turns to when they cross the line. When the blow-dried troglodytes and leggy blond idiots take some issue too far, Smith comes on with a reassuring break in the insanity to provide the propaganda network some CYA insurance. Freedom of speech and of the press is a great thing, but even in our system it has limits. The noise machine has lately been shouting "Fire!" in the crowded theater of America's living rooms on Ebola, feeding nicely into the extreme right's conspiracy-fueled madness.
It would be great if this Ebola Zombie business was a way to punk cable news, and provide that left hook of incredulity to shock the dumb from our collective consciousness. But according to Weathers the public has been just eating it up, even if the stories are coming from parody and satire sites. Max Brooks took on this topic in World War Z
where a character laments the conflicting commentary and misinformation from media during the denial and great panic stages of the zombie war. "So much spin, so few facts" or words to that effect.
I guess it is too much to wish for that the professional journalists of our time rise above the level of a comment section troll or people would not fall for something as stupid as Ebola creating zombies.
Before the current pop culture fascination with the living dead I had an idea to write a thriller about the zombie apocalypse occurring in the midst of complete governmental and societal dysfunction. But I never thought it would actually happen. Now we get to see how our eviscerated government, useless for-profit media, and large minority of completely insane and rabid 'wingers react to an outbreak of this dangerous disease. As much as I would like to believe Shepard Smith that we have absolutely nothing to fear, the truth is that the danger is not zero. Nor is it so great as to warrant the hysteria you see on the news.
Shep Smith is the guy Fox News turns to when they cross the line. When the blow-dried troglodytes and leggy blond idiots take some issue too far, Smith comes on with a reassuring break in the insanity to provide the propaganda network some CYA insurance. Freedom of speech and of the press is a great thing, but even in our system it has limits. The noise machine has lately been shouting "Fire!" in the crowded theater of America's living rooms on Ebola, feeding nicely into the extreme right's conspiracy-fueled madness.
It would be great if this Ebola Zombie business was a way to punk cable news, and provide that left hook of incredulity to shock the dumb from our collective consciousness. But according to Weathers the public has been just eating it up, even if the stories are coming from parody and satire sites. Max Brooks took on this topic in World War Z
I guess it is too much to wish for that the professional journalists of our time rise above the level of a comment section troll or people would not fall for something as stupid as Ebola creating zombies.
Thursday, October 23, 2014
Gas Price Conspiracy
The comment section strikes again! I posted a link on my Facebook page yesterday from The News Hour on PBS discussing the recent decline in gas prices. The actual discussion was not very informative due to the short length of exchange between the host and an energy and commodities reporter with Bloomberg News. It is a fact worth reporting that the gouging has decreased by 40 cents, equating to "a $500 or $600 tax cut for every household." That being the profit tax of the oil industry levied after 9/11 and just ignored by politicians ever since. The participants breeze over a few contributing factors without much detail. Perhaps this is why the commenters took the initiative to offer some fun and fanciful explanations of their own imaginations.
I have always found the correlation between the noticeable drop in gas prices the proximity to elections rather fascinating. Whether by accident or design the phenomenon defuses the profit tax and associated problems with energy as campaign issues. But my imagination has always been rather limited. So let's have a look at some of the more exciting/ominous reasons for relief at the pump.
As Powers Boothe said to Lea Thompson in Red Dawn
, "you've just seen too many movies darling."
I have always found the correlation between the noticeable drop in gas prices the proximity to elections rather fascinating. Whether by accident or design the phenomenon defuses the profit tax and associated problems with energy as campaign issues. But my imagination has always been rather limited. So let's have a look at some of the more exciting/ominous reasons for relief at the pump.
This all about Russia - Putin needs to go, so there is a deal between Obama and OPEC. Low as we can go - let them bankrupt Putin's Russia.
MAYBE ONE REASON IS THAT SINCE THE ISIS TOOK OVER SOME OIL WELLS IN IRAQ THEY BEGAN TO SELL OIL AT A VERY MUCH LOWER PRICE THAT CONSUMERS RUSHED TO BUY FROM THEN SECRETLY....
Here's why in a nutshell.The Gulf monarchies are flooding the market to bring the price of oil down so "Fracking" isn't profitable.They want to put the American and Canadian companies out of business.Because a lot of debt is incurred while producing oil through fracking,and it's more expensive to refine oil in "tar sands",all the monarchies have to do is keep up the increased production until the "frackers" go bankrupt. With the "90 day corporate mentality" we have here in the States,it won't be long before the monarchies achieve their goal.When we stop our expensive oil production,they'll go back to their OPEC quotas and raise prices.They have enough reserves to put every "fracking" wildcatter out of business.
Previous explanations of why the price of gasoline remained high even when crude oil prices fell, usually included the lack of capacity to refine more. Have we suddenly built more refineries? Not that I have heard about.
Over the past several election cycles, I have noticed a pattern between fuel prices and the party which holds the White House. As election time nears, if there is a Republican president, fuel prices increase before the election. The opposite holds true when there is a Democrat in the White House. the tie-in is usually not as strong for mid-term elections as during a presidential campaign.
Four things control the price of every thing. Not in any order of significance. Supply, demand, delivery cost, politics. A week after the elections the price will go up to cover the loss, plus fifty percent. As with anything the more you sell, the item price goes down, so when electric cars are the standard transport and petrol based vehicles wane the price for petroleum will sky rocket. Democrats will have sold their soles to get this price drop just before a critical election looms. One payoff I bet on will be new pipelines from the fracking sites to the east and west coasts. Just watch the laws and regulations melt away. This is funnier than a dropped match in a fireworks factory.
Also, note that Middle East turmoil, such as is now occurring in Syria and Iraq, plus sanctions on Iran, would traditionally send the price of crude, and of gasoline up quite high, are having no effect now.
Argues strongly that politics has more to do with the price than market forces.
the magic number they used to use was $65,was what they needed to make a profitYou get the idea. I did not copy links that some included but you can find them in the original. Isn't it awesome that PBS has so many budding geopolitical strategists they can tap?
then they said $90,now they say $83
speculators have added $20 to the price
they told us that if we export American oil prices will drop,because speculators are awash with oil with no place to send it,look at the big wall st firms profits,a lot of that is from oil
even at this price your going to see more electric cars on the road,or hybred,
I also agree with the comment below its an election year,so they drop the price of oil until its over,
Saudi cant drop output as it has to keep the natives happy,so they don't overthrow the royal family,they need the money,
As Powers Boothe said to Lea Thompson in Red Dawn
Wednesday, October 22, 2014
Michael Savage Must Be Stopped
Over a decade of endless warfare has left this country with many damaged souls. Now, one of the most vile screechers on talk radio has finally gone too far. Michael Savage, the devil of San Francisco, recently went on a tirade attacking veterans with PTSD as a "bunch of losers." Of all the venom-spewing psychos on the AM dial, Savage has always been the worst. Now, finally, this pantywaist chicken hawk who never wore a uniform or thought of anyone's wellbeing beyond his own narcissistic ass may get what he deserves.
After my own tour of duty I spent several years working in a factory. The local AM station replayed his awful show at midnight during my shift and I would tune in in an effort to stay awake while working. Between an incredible display of hatred for all things not Michael Savage, juvenile insults and name calling from a man who purportedly holds two Ph.Ds, and his yelling/spitting delivery I would get so angry that I was alert and awake beyond anything coffee could do for me. His racism, misogyny, and outright fascism has earned him a special place in hell. If he even has a soul. I always imagined that he would split down the middle during one of his rants about vermin (immigrants), demoncats (guess), filthy scum (anyone receiving public assistance), or other colorful metaphors about Muslims and a stream of cockroaches or maggots would pour out.
Again, for an individual with two Ph.Ds., there is remarkably little insight or intellectual creativity to his hate. I do not recall an original thought or line of reasoning from him, just vitriolic streams of invective for which ever Democrat happened to be in the news that day. Savage is the epitome of what the great conservative intellectual James Burnham described in Suicide of the West
. Anti-liberal individuals will use the liberal society's freedom against it to destroy society and liberty. Burnham meant communist agents working for the Soviet bloc but his ideas apply to anyone opposed to liberal values like freedom of speech and for the press. At best, Savage is the equivalent of intellectual empty calories, more realistically his show is an incitement to violence.
With his attacks on veterans with PTSD he has entered dangerous territory. There is no telling how many lone wolf terrorists he has anonymously programmed to go forth and destroy. I for one will not grieve if one realizes he's been had and comes home for revenge.
After my own tour of duty I spent several years working in a factory. The local AM station replayed his awful show at midnight during my shift and I would tune in in an effort to stay awake while working. Between an incredible display of hatred for all things not Michael Savage, juvenile insults and name calling from a man who purportedly holds two Ph.Ds, and his yelling/spitting delivery I would get so angry that I was alert and awake beyond anything coffee could do for me. His racism, misogyny, and outright fascism has earned him a special place in hell. If he even has a soul. I always imagined that he would split down the middle during one of his rants about vermin (immigrants), demoncats (guess), filthy scum (anyone receiving public assistance), or other colorful metaphors about Muslims and a stream of cockroaches or maggots would pour out.
Again, for an individual with two Ph.Ds., there is remarkably little insight or intellectual creativity to his hate. I do not recall an original thought or line of reasoning from him, just vitriolic streams of invective for which ever Democrat happened to be in the news that day. Savage is the epitome of what the great conservative intellectual James Burnham described in Suicide of the West
With his attacks on veterans with PTSD he has entered dangerous territory. There is no telling how many lone wolf terrorists he has anonymously programmed to go forth and destroy. I for one will not grieve if one realizes he's been had and comes home for revenge.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)