Couldn't have said it better.
Economic Tribalism
Hmm. This seems to be meta Saturday, with reactions to how people think – or, all too often, don’t think — about economics taking center stage.
Justin Fox has an interesting post documenting something I more or less knew, but am glad to see confirmed: People aren’t very receptive to evidence if it doesn’t come from a member of their cultural community. This has been blindingly obvious these past few years.
Consider what the different sides in economic debate have been predicting these past six or seven years. If you got your views from, say, the Wall Street Journal editorial page, you knew – knew – that there was no housing bubble, that America in 2008 wasn’t in recession, that budget deficits would send interest rates sky-high, that the Fed’s expansion of its balance sheet would produce huge inflation, that austerity policies would lead to economic expansion.
That’s quite a record. And yet I’m well aware that many people – including people with real money at stake – consider the WSJ a reliable source and people like, well, me flaky and unbelievable. Much of this is politics, of course, but that’s intertwined with culture: the kind of people who turn to the WSJ, or right-wing investment sites can clearly see that I’m a latte-sipping liberal who probably favors gay rights and doesn’t worship the financially successful (I actually prefer good filter coffee, black, but that’s otherwise accurate), and just not part of their tribe.
I suppose that in my quest to improve policy and understanding I should be trying to fit in better – lose the beard, learn to play golf, start using “impact” as a verb. But I probably couldn’t pull it off even if I tried. And as a result there will always be a large group of people who will never be moved by any evidence I present.
Actually, I had a wonderful, in a way, piece of correspondence today; the correspondent had read End this Depression Now!, and was having trouble finding any instances where I presented facts deceptively to support my ideological agenda. Could I please help him locate the places in the book where I do that?
Oh well. We just do what we can.
Update: Or, to illustrate, let me quote a voice mail I got recently (as rendered by Microsoft speech technology — I won’t actually listen to the thing):
Yeah hi Paul Krugman please this is for you I seen you on CNN last night with Anderson cooper.
And your as always you’re so far message unbelievable you’re falcon liar you’re fall issue yet and you are so liberal it’s unbelievable but you keep — keep talking that she had and you keep back and — mr obama — and now when users is that maybe you lose your parking job not sure when one my kids and if you’re ready coming classes.
Update update: You know, I hadn’t quite realized what he meant by “falcon liar”. But now I do — and I guess I get what it means to say I’m “fall issue” too.
I think I get the gist.
This was just a post on Paul Krugman's blog, the source article is here. At it's core:
"People feel that it is safe to consider evidence with an open mind when they know that a knowledgeable member of their cultural community accepts it."
I for one, like to read about other cultural communities. The problem is when tribalism in this community rends any common understanding. There is truth about the economy, and then there is truthiness.
Sunday, May 6, 2012
Authorship problems
The zombie told me that he can't log in using his own email because it had previously been associated with this blog. Bummer, he started this thing and now can't even take direct credit when he writes on it. We are a lot alike but there is a subtle difference in the tone of our writing. Yesterday he had a few thoughts to get off of his chest. Food trucks in Sheboygan and increased fees on them. I don't do facebook but he does and he saw somebody talking about it. Now, we both have a pet peeve about economics. Isaac Asimov's quote comes to mind: “Anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that 'my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.'”
Certainly, people have the right to complain. But really, they don't want to know how their politics or sausage is made. Since when is paying taxes the worst thing in the world? It really has gone beyond objecting to how tax revenue is used, and become the idea that all taxation is illegitimate. I admit targetting small business and new businesses like this is low-hanging fruit. They do not have lawyers and lobbyists that big business have. American culture is coarse, individualistic, and often very aggressive. On top of that most people are selfish by nature.The average joe on the street does not see all the things that happened to make society, the economy, and government possible. This blog you are reading right now has a lot of sausage-making going on behind it that you don't see, unless you are extremely proficient in code-writing and all of the other technical aspects. Just reading this blog also puts you in debt to all the past efforts making the internet and all this technology that has enhanced our lives, possible in the first place. The real cost of having a decent country, or state, or city to live in goes far beyond what anyone pays in taxes. Rome was not built in a day, as the saying goes.
Just a few thoughts for anyone willing to consider them. Questioning authority is good, but complaining for the sake of complaining or because it just crimps one's lifestyle a bit makes you look less like a jealous ex- and more like a toddler throwing a tantrum. It is a balance and obviously not everyone feels the same way about it. I suppose the zombie and I will continue to be accused of elitism for making a reasonable request like doing a little research before wildly slinging accusations. Or using juvenile ad hominem attacks and other fallacies instead of a real debate. Or, God forbid, having a little trust that the people you elect to govern your town might have some idea about what they are doing.
Anyway, the zombie is going to go back to his crypt, or grave, or wherever he goes. He is a little disgusted that the state of intertubes debate is still this bad. One post and he got a nasty comment, pretty discouraging. What the heck man? I've insulted many people far worse and barely ever get comments lol.
Certainly, people have the right to complain. But really, they don't want to know how their politics or sausage is made. Since when is paying taxes the worst thing in the world? It really has gone beyond objecting to how tax revenue is used, and become the idea that all taxation is illegitimate. I admit targetting small business and new businesses like this is low-hanging fruit. They do not have lawyers and lobbyists that big business have. American culture is coarse, individualistic, and often very aggressive. On top of that most people are selfish by nature.The average joe on the street does not see all the things that happened to make society, the economy, and government possible. This blog you are reading right now has a lot of sausage-making going on behind it that you don't see, unless you are extremely proficient in code-writing and all of the other technical aspects. Just reading this blog also puts you in debt to all the past efforts making the internet and all this technology that has enhanced our lives, possible in the first place. The real cost of having a decent country, or state, or city to live in goes far beyond what anyone pays in taxes. Rome was not built in a day, as the saying goes.
Just a few thoughts for anyone willing to consider them. Questioning authority is good, but complaining for the sake of complaining or because it just crimps one's lifestyle a bit makes you look less like a jealous ex- and more like a toddler throwing a tantrum. It is a balance and obviously not everyone feels the same way about it. I suppose the zombie and I will continue to be accused of elitism for making a reasonable request like doing a little research before wildly slinging accusations. Or using juvenile ad hominem attacks and other fallacies instead of a real debate. Or, God forbid, having a little trust that the people you elect to govern your town might have some idea about what they are doing.
Anyway, the zombie is going to go back to his crypt, or grave, or wherever he goes. He is a little disgusted that the state of intertubes debate is still this bad. One post and he got a nasty comment, pretty discouraging. What the heck man? I've insulted many people far worse and barely ever get comments lol.
Saturday, May 5, 2012
Food Truck Regulation (zombie speaking)
I just saw some people discussing this story from my hometown Sheboygan Press.
Proposed City of Sheboygan ordinance would limit activity of food trucks

Sounds kind of good, I could handle a Gyro right about now. There was a Middle Eastern food truck (or maybe it was Greek) at Summerfest one year that served the best falafel. I watched the Great Food Truck Race on Food Network religiously both seasons it has been on. Food trucks seem to be the latest fad around, and good for them. It is an interesting and novel business. But make no mistake, it is a business, operators are just as cutthroat as a small business can be.
Therefore, when I heard comments about how awful it was that the city was raising fees on the trucks, I smelled a rat.
"The ordinance, which was unanimously recommended for approval by the city Law and Licensing Committee, also would increase the fees paid by vendors from $100 to $500."
Part of a comment went like this:
"But the rest seems to be standard "justify our existence" and "Moneygrab" crap. Just let everyone sell their stuff, (The $100 fee was perfectly fine before, why not now all of a sudden? This is one of my biggest beefs with government currently. The costs go up (fee's/taxes) and yet the level of service we receive in return is lower than ever, and going down... what the hell? I understand increased costs, but if we pay more, at a minimum, shouldn't the level of service be the same?) and get the hell out of the way! This is why nothing ever happens around here. There's always some government body with a hand out, and a form to fill out, and it quickly goes from "This could be a cool idea!" to "Oh... the hell with it! It's just not worth it!"
This is from the same guy that defended the former mayor's right to get falling-down drunk in public.
"Moneygrab" love it. His governor yanked away all sorts of funding for local services, said cities can't raise property taxes to offset the cuts, but this guy acts like the fees will be going into the councilmembers pockets. Oh well, understanding economics was never his strong suit.
Now, there is no mention of whether this fee is annual, or just initial when you apply to open a business. If it is one time, then a fact escaped the guys whining about it. Even if annual, this is standard operating procedure for local businesses. Yes, the same crowd that objects to smoking bans is going to cry that they cannot get food after stumbling out of the bar at 2:30 am. But, the established truckers bought themselves a ticket out of competition. Service suffers when you have official protection, no fear from a new guy in the business who might care more about serving drunks. You might not oppose some regulation so strongly if it also meant your market share would be protected by law. Just pass on the cost increases to themarks customers.
Someday, I have hope that my friend here will realize that business is ammoral. They do not exist to "serve" you, they exist to separate you from your money. This kind of corruption is insidious, it breaks one of the central tenets of capitalism. That being unobstructed entry and exit from the market. Perfect information is another tenet, competition is only fair when people know what is going on. But hey, it's all about you right? And your rights and your freedom.
I am so glad I escaped from this culture.
Proposed City of Sheboygan ordinance would limit activity of food trucks
Sounds kind of good, I could handle a Gyro right about now. There was a Middle Eastern food truck (or maybe it was Greek) at Summerfest one year that served the best falafel. I watched the Great Food Truck Race on Food Network religiously both seasons it has been on. Food trucks seem to be the latest fad around, and good for them. It is an interesting and novel business. But make no mistake, it is a business, operators are just as cutthroat as a small business can be.
Therefore, when I heard comments about how awful it was that the city was raising fees on the trucks, I smelled a rat.
"The ordinance, which was unanimously recommended for approval by the city Law and Licensing Committee, also would increase the fees paid by vendors from $100 to $500."
Part of a comment went like this:
"But the rest seems to be standard "justify our existence" and "Moneygrab" crap. Just let everyone sell their stuff, (The $100 fee was perfectly fine before, why not now all of a sudden? This is one of my biggest beefs with government currently. The costs go up (fee's/taxes) and yet the level of service we receive in return is lower than ever, and going down... what the hell? I understand increased costs, but if we pay more, at a minimum, shouldn't the level of service be the same?) and get the hell out of the way! This is why nothing ever happens around here. There's always some government body with a hand out, and a form to fill out, and it quickly goes from "This could be a cool idea!" to "Oh... the hell with it! It's just not worth it!"
This is from the same guy that defended the former mayor's right to get falling-down drunk in public.
"Moneygrab" love it. His governor yanked away all sorts of funding for local services, said cities can't raise property taxes to offset the cuts, but this guy acts like the fees will be going into the councilmembers pockets. Oh well, understanding economics was never his strong suit.
Now, there is no mention of whether this fee is annual, or just initial when you apply to open a business. If it is one time, then a fact escaped the guys whining about it. Even if annual, this is standard operating procedure for local businesses. Yes, the same crowd that objects to smoking bans is going to cry that they cannot get food after stumbling out of the bar at 2:30 am. But, the established truckers bought themselves a ticket out of competition. Service suffers when you have official protection, no fear from a new guy in the business who might care more about serving drunks. You might not oppose some regulation so strongly if it also meant your market share would be protected by law. Just pass on the cost increases to the
Someday, I have hope that my friend here will realize that business is ammoral. They do not exist to "serve" you, they exist to separate you from your money. This kind of corruption is insidious, it breaks one of the central tenets of capitalism. That being unobstructed entry and exit from the market. Perfect information is another tenet, competition is only fair when people know what is going on. But hey, it's all about you right? And your rights and your freedom.
I am so glad I escaped from this culture.
Debate Analysis
Wisconsin needs a new governor. That much is certain. To start off, I'll go out on a limb here and say that all the farmers and freaks with "I stand with walker" signs would have been quite at home in Soviet Russia. Submitting to authority and aggressing against whatever groups that authority dislikes is part and parcel of right-wing authoritarian followers. It is also why anyone standing with walker should automatically be dismissed as undeserving of a say in our future. Luckily, over a million Wisconsinites stood up against authoritarianism and recalled scott walker. For you conservative curmudgeons out there, recall exists for elected officials who deceived the public to gain office and execute that office contrary to the public interest. This is, after all, what a republic is, a government formed to carry out the public's interest. It has been the great coup of social dominating republicans to convince so many citizens that teachers are a special interest while the koch brothers are the public's interest.
So, the machinery has worked the way it was supposed to. A governor who campaigned on jobs but then "dropped the bomb" as the oft-repeated phrase from last night put it, on working people will face a recall election. Walker even threatened to call out the national guard if anyone dared oppose him as though he was a robber baron in the Nineteenth Century. Sorry scotty, this isn't the Soviet Union yet. Recall is an extreme provision, meant to be difficult to accomplish but walker has proved at every opportunity that he is unfit to govern in a democracy. That is also why republican attempts at recall have been more difficult, you can disagree over policy while still serving the public interest. Let them continue to agitate, the more the public sees of it, the more they will understand that republican recall efforts are simple power grabs and not a safeguarding of the public interest.
Last night, four Democratic office-holders met to debate issues of the day. Each made their case for unseating walker and why they should be his successor. The choice has come down to Democratic conservatism, trying to hang on to or restore a system that worked rather well for over two generations, or republican authoritarianism. The koch brothers, ALEC, and the management complex believes the Republic exists to serve them alone, and they are willing to spend any amount neccessary to take it from us. There used to be a saying that what is good for GM is good for America, and there may have been some truth in that when capitalism actually meant making things and building things. After three decades of Bain-style speculative and predatory capitalism, however, this is as untrue as saying America needs a monarch.
Tom Barrett, Kathleen Falk, Doug La Follette, and Kathleen Vinehout debated the issues of the day last night, not these larger philosophical questions. They were united in the effort to replace walker and shared 90% of commonwealth and public interest positions. Because any one of them would be an incredible improvement on what walker has done, and none of the candidates "won" in the conventional sense, it is a difficult choice. But those million voters who oppose walker's blatant abuse of power must coalesce around one and only one opponent.
What we really need is an anti-walker, someone who will fight for the commonwealth and public interest just as ferociously as walker fought for special interests and power. Just as America really needed an aggressive liberal after bush slinked back to texas. What we got nationally was a constitutional law professor, capable of great speeches but technocratic in nature and unable for much of his term to confront the ideological war going on. What we need is someone with "fire in their belly" who will stop apologizing for being a Democrat. What we will probably get is a grandfather type, most likely unequal to the task of overcoming vehement obstruction to simply reverse nearly two years of vicious undermining of our state and society. Yes, I voted for Barrett last time and will gladly vote for him again. But he is not the leader we need. In a more normal time, he would have a long career managing the state in a pragmatic fashion, similar to the way Tommy Thompson did. This is not to say he will simply be a manager the way President Obama has been for most of his term, but he is not the leader who can push the koches and their authoritarian machine out of the limelight and back into the closet where they belong.
So, the machinery has worked the way it was supposed to. A governor who campaigned on jobs but then "dropped the bomb" as the oft-repeated phrase from last night put it, on working people will face a recall election. Walker even threatened to call out the national guard if anyone dared oppose him as though he was a robber baron in the Nineteenth Century. Sorry scotty, this isn't the Soviet Union yet. Recall is an extreme provision, meant to be difficult to accomplish but walker has proved at every opportunity that he is unfit to govern in a democracy. That is also why republican attempts at recall have been more difficult, you can disagree over policy while still serving the public interest. Let them continue to agitate, the more the public sees of it, the more they will understand that republican recall efforts are simple power grabs and not a safeguarding of the public interest.
Last night, four Democratic office-holders met to debate issues of the day. Each made their case for unseating walker and why they should be his successor. The choice has come down to Democratic conservatism, trying to hang on to or restore a system that worked rather well for over two generations, or republican authoritarianism. The koch brothers, ALEC, and the management complex believes the Republic exists to serve them alone, and they are willing to spend any amount neccessary to take it from us. There used to be a saying that what is good for GM is good for America, and there may have been some truth in that when capitalism actually meant making things and building things. After three decades of Bain-style speculative and predatory capitalism, however, this is as untrue as saying America needs a monarch.
Tom Barrett, Kathleen Falk, Doug La Follette, and Kathleen Vinehout debated the issues of the day last night, not these larger philosophical questions. They were united in the effort to replace walker and shared 90% of commonwealth and public interest positions. Because any one of them would be an incredible improvement on what walker has done, and none of the candidates "won" in the conventional sense, it is a difficult choice. But those million voters who oppose walker's blatant abuse of power must coalesce around one and only one opponent.
What we really need is an anti-walker, someone who will fight for the commonwealth and public interest just as ferociously as walker fought for special interests and power. Just as America really needed an aggressive liberal after bush slinked back to texas. What we got nationally was a constitutional law professor, capable of great speeches but technocratic in nature and unable for much of his term to confront the ideological war going on. What we need is someone with "fire in their belly" who will stop apologizing for being a Democrat. What we will probably get is a grandfather type, most likely unequal to the task of overcoming vehement obstruction to simply reverse nearly two years of vicious undermining of our state and society. Yes, I voted for Barrett last time and will gladly vote for him again. But he is not the leader we need. In a more normal time, he would have a long career managing the state in a pragmatic fashion, similar to the way Tommy Thompson did. This is not to say he will simply be a manager the way President Obama has been for most of his term, but he is not the leader who can push the koches and their authoritarian machine out of the limelight and back into the closet where they belong.
Friday, May 4, 2012
Democratic Gubernatorial Debate
Tom Barrett, Kathleen Falk, Kathleen Vinehout, and Doug La Follette are debating right now for the Democratic nomination to face scott walker in the recall election. It is hard to keep up.
First question was about collective bargaining. All candidates support restoring those rights for public workers. Barrett was forcefully in favor of getting it done this summer by any of several methods.
Medicaid. Vinehout claims $2bil is misallocated because of poorly run contractors, Act 10 gives governor too much authority to mess the system up.
So far, Falk does remind me of the caricature of stiff, eggheaded liberals that slimy propagandists constantly push.
La Follette just seems too old to really carry this fight through. He has put forward his family name's "Wisconsin Idea" on several occasions.
Vinehout sounds really hoarse. Very passionate about the environment though, advocates giving DNR more freedom to work and allow them to testify in front of the leg. She really says great things. It is a complete "duh" that contractors are doing public work that government workers could do themselves for much less.
Barrett: "Economic growth and environmental protection are not enemies"
Falk: get people working again, hold her to that in two years. Heal state. Throw walker in jail (oh wait, that's me) Falk wants to be state's "Mom"
Vinehout: roll back tax cuts, alternative budget. working people got tax raises by walker and affluent got cuts, (duh) she wants to roll things back to the way they were.
Barrett: tax cuts that are actually generating jobs will be held off from rolling back
stressed fairness. shared sacrifice. He's already fighting the general election. Rightly.
Falk: no tax hikes on working families. Rollback "Vegas" loophole to restore edu. funding
La Follette: get rid of loophole for out of state corps. GOOD. Argues he's most electable because he doesn't have the same hatred against him from wingnuts
Barrett: has son attending UW-Madison. Tech. schools cut funding. jobs are needed to get edu. funding. econ. must grow to get revenue
Falk: How to get jobs B? Edu. leads to jobs, need educated workers to innovate for manufacturing
Vinehout: more revenue available in this budget than last, edu just not a priority for sheithead walker
"NOT ALL SMART STUDENTS ARE RICH" deserve shot if you're working class
Tim Hanna Mayor of Appleton "how to repair partisanship?"
Falk: Keep family together and allow all to save face
La Follette: civility, no special interest agenda, can sit down with all sides, scientific background
Vinehout: calm turmoil around state, "gov 'herself'" restore civil environment, open door, follow laws, no secrecy, gov sets tone, calm and respectful tone necessary
Barrett: mayors get together and discuss things without partisanship, local level pragmatism, respect for people you disagree with.
Heart with Vinehout, head says Barrett.
Oohh, V just said "vote Democrat" have to inform her what that slip means. Can we at least not shoot the team by framing out.
Barrett can admit there is an ideological civil war here in WI since walker slinked into office. Don't agree with his thoughts on ending war, but at least he can admit it.
Falk, cheap shot at B. Smiling insincerely.
First question was about collective bargaining. All candidates support restoring those rights for public workers. Barrett was forcefully in favor of getting it done this summer by any of several methods.
Medicaid. Vinehout claims $2bil is misallocated because of poorly run contractors, Act 10 gives governor too much authority to mess the system up.
So far, Falk does remind me of the caricature of stiff, eggheaded liberals that slimy propagandists constantly push.
La Follette just seems too old to really carry this fight through. He has put forward his family name's "Wisconsin Idea" on several occasions.
Vinehout sounds really hoarse. Very passionate about the environment though, advocates giving DNR more freedom to work and allow them to testify in front of the leg. She really says great things. It is a complete "duh" that contractors are doing public work that government workers could do themselves for much less.
Barrett: "Economic growth and environmental protection are not enemies"
Falk: get people working again, hold her to that in two years. Heal state. Throw walker in jail (oh wait, that's me) Falk wants to be state's "Mom"
Vinehout: roll back tax cuts, alternative budget. working people got tax raises by walker and affluent got cuts, (duh) she wants to roll things back to the way they were.
Barrett: tax cuts that are actually generating jobs will be held off from rolling back
stressed fairness. shared sacrifice. He's already fighting the general election. Rightly.
Falk: no tax hikes on working families. Rollback "Vegas" loophole to restore edu. funding
La Follette: get rid of loophole for out of state corps. GOOD. Argues he's most electable because he doesn't have the same hatred against him from wingnuts
Barrett: has son attending UW-Madison. Tech. schools cut funding. jobs are needed to get edu. funding. econ. must grow to get revenue
Falk: How to get jobs B? Edu. leads to jobs, need educated workers to innovate for manufacturing
Vinehout: more revenue available in this budget than last, edu just not a priority for sheithead walker
"NOT ALL SMART STUDENTS ARE RICH" deserve shot if you're working class
Tim Hanna Mayor of Appleton "how to repair partisanship?"
Falk: Keep family together and allow all to save face
La Follette: civility, no special interest agenda, can sit down with all sides, scientific background
Vinehout: calm turmoil around state, "gov 'herself'" restore civil environment, open door, follow laws, no secrecy, gov sets tone, calm and respectful tone necessary
Barrett: mayors get together and discuss things without partisanship, local level pragmatism, respect for people you disagree with.
Heart with Vinehout, head says Barrett.
Oohh, V just said "vote Democrat" have to inform her what that slip means. Can we at least not shoot the team by framing out.
Barrett can admit there is an ideological civil war here in WI since walker slinked into office. Don't agree with his thoughts on ending war, but at least he can admit it.
Falk, cheap shot at B. Smiling insincerely.
Thursday, May 3, 2012
More violence
A study in contrasts.
In a country that endures around 10,000 murders a year, mostly from guns, we get some strange reporting on violence sometimes.
I saw this story floating around the intertubes yesterday.
Many blacks beat white couple, media bury attack
But the catch headline was more specific:
100 BLACKS BEAT WHITE COUPLE, MEDIA BURY ATTACK
Just for fun (and a sinking suspicion that this wasn't quite right) I fed the second headline into google and got 914,000 hits. Wingnuts were plastering the story all over the place in social media and news comment sections. It never seems to occur to writers like this that they are part of the media.
"There’s outrage in Norfolk, Va., today after a white couple was attacked by dozens of black teenagers, and the local newspaper did not report on the incident for two weeks, despite the victims being reporters for the paper."
I guess when you're making a propaganda point dozens is the same as 100.
In the report "neither suffered grave injuries, but both were out of work for a week. Forster’s torso ached from blows to his ribs, and he retained a thumb-sized bump on his head. Rostami reportedly fears to be alone in her home, while Forster wishes he’d stayed in the car."
So besides the racist implications for those that seem bent on race war, there was no serious injuries. Very scary for sure, I would not want to be rushed by dozens of angry people no matter how much melenin their skin contained. But at least it wasn't an apocalyptic murder suicide.
Oh wait, here's one.
Border Guard founder J.T. Ready blamed in Arizona murder-suicide
From the Los Angeles Times
"Jason Todd Ready never made a secret of his passion for right-wing politics and related causes, both of which got the bearded, barrel-chested former Marine branded a racist, an extremist and a bigot. In a lifetime of moving through mainstream politics in Arizona as well as within the semi-military world of less-established groups, Ready built a reputation for in-your-face confrontations, founding an armed volunteer group dedicated to patrolling the Mexico border and ending the smuggling of illegal immigrants and drugs.
On Wednesday, Ready entered a Gilbert, Ariz., home and opened fire, killing four people, including a 15-month-old girl, said Gilbert Police Sgt. Bill Balafas. Ready then turned a handgun on himself, ending his life at age 39, the sergeant said."
I wonder what the wingnut meme will be for this one. J.T. Ready was a folk hero in certain segments of the the wingnutosphere. You know, standing up for our borders and such like.
Talking Points Memo elaborated on the military hardware found at the scene.
"[ATF agent] Mangan described the bombs as 40mm armor-piercing projectile grenades, the same type used by the U.S. military in combat. The grenades are generally fired from some sort of launcher, but Mangan said no such weapon was found at the scene."
I am not trying to establish equivalance, I am not casting judgement. Just noting the continuing violence in this society. Before any trolls try to provoke, yes the assailants in the first case should be arrested and charged with assault. The second should be investigated thoroughly, but with a murder suicide there is not much that can really be done. Probably not the last we will hear from the story though. Are we ever going to say enough with violence?
In a country that endures around 10,000 murders a year, mostly from guns, we get some strange reporting on violence sometimes.
I saw this story floating around the intertubes yesterday.
Many blacks beat white couple, media bury attack
But the catch headline was more specific:
100 BLACKS BEAT WHITE COUPLE, MEDIA BURY ATTACK
Just for fun (and a sinking suspicion that this wasn't quite right) I fed the second headline into google and got 914,000 hits. Wingnuts were plastering the story all over the place in social media and news comment sections. It never seems to occur to writers like this that they are part of the media.
"There’s outrage in Norfolk, Va., today after a white couple was attacked by dozens of black teenagers, and the local newspaper did not report on the incident for two weeks, despite the victims being reporters for the paper."
I guess when you're making a propaganda point dozens is the same as 100.
In the report "neither suffered grave injuries, but both were out of work for a week. Forster’s torso ached from blows to his ribs, and he retained a thumb-sized bump on his head. Rostami reportedly fears to be alone in her home, while Forster wishes he’d stayed in the car."
So besides the racist implications for those that seem bent on race war, there was no serious injuries. Very scary for sure, I would not want to be rushed by dozens of angry people no matter how much melenin their skin contained. But at least it wasn't an apocalyptic murder suicide.
Oh wait, here's one.
Border Guard founder J.T. Ready blamed in Arizona murder-suicide
From the Los Angeles Times
"Jason Todd Ready never made a secret of his passion for right-wing politics and related causes, both of which got the bearded, barrel-chested former Marine branded a racist, an extremist and a bigot. In a lifetime of moving through mainstream politics in Arizona as well as within the semi-military world of less-established groups, Ready built a reputation for in-your-face confrontations, founding an armed volunteer group dedicated to patrolling the Mexico border and ending the smuggling of illegal immigrants and drugs.
On Wednesday, Ready entered a Gilbert, Ariz., home and opened fire, killing four people, including a 15-month-old girl, said Gilbert Police Sgt. Bill Balafas. Ready then turned a handgun on himself, ending his life at age 39, the sergeant said."
I wonder what the wingnut meme will be for this one. J.T. Ready was a folk hero in certain segments of the the wingnutosphere. You know, standing up for our borders and such like.
Talking Points Memo elaborated on the military hardware found at the scene.
"[ATF agent] Mangan described the bombs as 40mm armor-piercing projectile grenades, the same type used by the U.S. military in combat. The grenades are generally fired from some sort of launcher, but Mangan said no such weapon was found at the scene."
I am not trying to establish equivalance, I am not casting judgement. Just noting the continuing violence in this society. Before any trolls try to provoke, yes the assailants in the first case should be arrested and charged with assault. The second should be investigated thoroughly, but with a murder suicide there is not much that can really be done. Probably not the last we will hear from the story though. Are we ever going to say enough with violence?
Ron Paul for President (spoiler alert, this post is not serious)
As a protest vote against the utter insanity and mockery of American democratic values and degradation of an honest and responsible conservative alternative that the republican party has become? Yes.
As a serious solution to very real challenges facing the American republic? Not so much.
Brush up on your penmanship skills Paul fans, you will need to write him in. There is next to zero chance Paul will seek a nomination on any third-party platform. Doing so would jeopardise his son's career in republican politics.
A Paul administration would very likely result in even more gridlock and disfunction in DC than there is now. Most Democrats reject his platform of eviserating the federal government. Republicans would obstruct his agenda more out of spite than anything. While as chief executive, Paul would likely take the veto pen to any legislation sent to him that involved spending any money.
Objectively, the Paul platform is just too radical. His agenda involves immediate and deep spending cuts that would cause a great number of contracting companies to go bankrupt in short order. The loss of income and purchasing power by all those employees inside and outside of government would cause a depression of unmatched magnitude. Possibly millions more would lose so much confidence in any products and services (food and medicine to say the least) regulated by the government. Beyond the physical damage caused by chaos in all sorts of commercial and financial sectors as companies big and small would jockey for position to outdo each other, the psychological impact of each death or injury would resonate in the real economy far out of proportion to real effects.
The American public tolerates the slow moves toward complete feudalism, debt peonage, and complete economic atomization. But the radical shock Paul's agenda would create in the public would almost certainly seize up the gears beyond repair. While multinationals and the very wealthy would benefit, they would be more dependent than ever on foreign markets and most likely mercenary guards to maintain their privilege.
But by all means, write him in. The practical ramifications of losing the presidency again will not do much to the republicans. It will buy the larger society four more years to try and fix things. Putting Paul's demostrated racism aside, it would be at least a symbolic rejection of the current republican values of war on everyone by young conservatives. The rigid hierarchy and totalitarian structure of the conservative movement today means the Paul supporters have no other option than complete abstention in order to have any hope of influencing republican policy orientation.
UPDATE.
There seems to be some confusion with this post. It was meant to be tongue-in-cheek. I am in no way endorsing screwball Ron Paul for anything. It started as a joke, then got serious, then went back to being a joke. Part of me wants his fans to write him in so they don't vote for Romney. While this wouldn't affect the same kind of protest that Naderites did in 2000, it would at least help keep lunatics out of the white house for a little longer. Visible conflict on the right would be a good thing though, if they are busy fighting each other as during the primaries, maybe the rest of us can try and fix a few things.
Laying my cards on the table. Yes, I was trying to pull a fast one on a not-too-politically-sophisticated friend who has been seduced by the dark side. Apparently, throwing something together like this in about five minutes wasn't bright, but I had to get back to work. Rereading it, my writing was rather confusing. If you're going to try and mess with people, don't halfheart it and throw in some legitimate criticism. I believe my state of mind was something along the lines of realizing that the self-proclaimed sophisticates who drool over Paul will fall in line for the general election, but many others who may be voting for the first time or not paying that much attention might be conned into throwing away their vote for him.
As a serious solution to very real challenges facing the American republic? Not so much.
Brush up on your penmanship skills Paul fans, you will need to write him in. There is next to zero chance Paul will seek a nomination on any third-party platform. Doing so would jeopardise his son's career in republican politics.
A Paul administration would very likely result in even more gridlock and disfunction in DC than there is now. Most Democrats reject his platform of eviserating the federal government. Republicans would obstruct his agenda more out of spite than anything. While as chief executive, Paul would likely take the veto pen to any legislation sent to him that involved spending any money.
Objectively, the Paul platform is just too radical. His agenda involves immediate and deep spending cuts that would cause a great number of contracting companies to go bankrupt in short order. The loss of income and purchasing power by all those employees inside and outside of government would cause a depression of unmatched magnitude. Possibly millions more would lose so much confidence in any products and services (food and medicine to say the least) regulated by the government. Beyond the physical damage caused by chaos in all sorts of commercial and financial sectors as companies big and small would jockey for position to outdo each other, the psychological impact of each death or injury would resonate in the real economy far out of proportion to real effects.
The American public tolerates the slow moves toward complete feudalism, debt peonage, and complete economic atomization. But the radical shock Paul's agenda would create in the public would almost certainly seize up the gears beyond repair. While multinationals and the very wealthy would benefit, they would be more dependent than ever on foreign markets and most likely mercenary guards to maintain their privilege.
But by all means, write him in. The practical ramifications of losing the presidency again will not do much to the republicans. It will buy the larger society four more years to try and fix things. Putting Paul's demostrated racism aside, it would be at least a symbolic rejection of the current republican values of war on everyone by young conservatives. The rigid hierarchy and totalitarian structure of the conservative movement today means the Paul supporters have no other option than complete abstention in order to have any hope of influencing republican policy orientation.
UPDATE.
There seems to be some confusion with this post. It was meant to be tongue-in-cheek. I am in no way endorsing screwball Ron Paul for anything. It started as a joke, then got serious, then went back to being a joke. Part of me wants his fans to write him in so they don't vote for Romney. While this wouldn't affect the same kind of protest that Naderites did in 2000, it would at least help keep lunatics out of the white house for a little longer. Visible conflict on the right would be a good thing though, if they are busy fighting each other as during the primaries, maybe the rest of us can try and fix a few things.
Laying my cards on the table. Yes, I was trying to pull a fast one on a not-too-politically-sophisticated friend who has been seduced by the dark side. Apparently, throwing something together like this in about five minutes wasn't bright, but I had to get back to work. Rereading it, my writing was rather confusing. If you're going to try and mess with people, don't halfheart it and throw in some legitimate criticism. I believe my state of mind was something along the lines of realizing that the self-proclaimed sophisticates who drool over Paul will fall in line for the general election, but many others who may be voting for the first time or not paying that much attention might be conned into throwing away their vote for him.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)