Monday, March 26, 2012

"The Blade Itself Incites To Violence"

This quote by the ancient blind Greek poet Homer seems to have been lost in the contemporary United States over violence. It makes a nice sloganesque response to the tired line "guns don't kill people, people kill people." So, after Trayvon Martin and Bo Morrisson were murdered by gun-wielding people, this picture started making its rounds.


No, but two did.
If justifiable homicide claims have tripled in florida then the odds that some of these (admittedly arbitrary) number HAVE killed someone in the last year.
If we update Homer's quote to "The Gun Itself Incites To Violence" it becomes more relevant today. Yes, as George Carlin once said "you could probably beat a guy to death with the Sunday New York Times" but that would be a lot more work than pulling a trigger, and much less likely to happen accidentally.
The truth is, yes a gun is a tool. But it is a tool with just one use.
I am speaking as a former Army Tanker who has shot bigger guns than most civilian gun enthusiasts.
Excuse me, "weapons." There is little hope of instilling any feeling of empathy for gunshot victims in those civilians, other than for each other's phallic symbols.
Another "truth," "responsible gun owner." This is not a binary condition. I am a responsible driver, but every once in a while I make a mistake. Even "gangbangers" in the ghetto manage not to shoot their balls off most of the time. Are they responsible gun owners? Oh, you mean, white people who are around guns and have taken classes. Okay. But familiarity breeds complacence. I was around guns all the time in the army and took classes. So it wasn't an uncomfortable experience. But when I saw a guy at the movies putting on his coat a little while back to cover the 9mm on his belt, I freaked. In the army weapons were a tool of the trade, at the movies, a gun is... what exactly? Did this fellow think he was gonna get in a shootout in Mequon (one of the richest, safest suburbs in WI)? Or was it because he was black in a pretty white place?
Ahhh, there it is. And no, I saw the gun first because I was waiting on a bench outside the theater. Seeing a gun carried by anyone is enough to make me anxious, it is just something that is out of place in civilian life. I am not going to rattle off any cliches about why creeps might want to carry a concealed (or not so concealed) weapon in public, but am I going to have to feel this anxious everytime I step out of my door from now on?
"The Gun Itself Incites To Violence" I can cause you harm if I choose. All other concerns seem secondary and I do not want to save a society that thinks this is moral or ethical, and especially if it is legal.

Keep speaking truth



http://crooksandliars.com/karoli/romney-admits-gop-education-policy-intended
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/features/2007/0701.drum.html
http://www.alternet.org/teaparty/154607/how_the_right-wing_brain_works_and_what_that_means_for_progressives/?page=2
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/george-lakoff/santorum-strategy_b_1338708.html

The Great Walker Delusion

One great thing about being a simpleton is you can believe whatever you want. Most reactionary dickmonkeys who weasel their way into office or other positions of power just play simpletons so their authoritarian submissive followers believe that the dickmonkey is "one of them." Scott Walker of Wisconsin however, is the real deal.

http://cognidissidence.blogspot.com/2012/03/when-haves-are-really-have-nots.html

Remember, if you can't spot the sucker at the table, it's you.
Though, I suppose when we kick this disgrace out of office the kochs will find some out of the way place for him where he can't do any damage to them or the fascist agenda. His "real money" will be more or less hush money to ensure that the next dickmonkey who spends the "hard time" necessary to sneak into office at such "low" compensation won't be deterred by the thought that after his "service" to real power he won't be dropped like a hot rock.

But why?

"If your 18 yrs old the law requires you to carry i.d. so whats the big deal if you have to show i.d. before voting? whats going to stop dishonest people that write mickey mouse on recall petitions from using my name to vote?"
This is an awfully odd way for a conservative, someone who supposedly values tradition and the status quo, to frame their support for stripping people of voting rights. But, this was one of many comments I found opposing the unconstitutional ruling on WI's voter ID law by a court. Left unsaid is the rigid conventionalism in minds like this, that everyone must live according to "my" standards. If you refuse to obey my will, then you pay the consequences. In this case, you can't vote because I believe (in spite of all evidence to the contrary) that voter fraud is throwing elections. Also left unsaid is the hatred of a democracy that elects people to office that disagree with me. It should be said that the commentor describes himself as a "libertarian" you know, someone who feels the government is too involved in our lives. So, forcing everyone to get a state-approved ID is in line with his small-government ideals when it will prevent anyone getting into office that might want to expand the role of government. But, consistancy is supposed to be a libertarian value, sigh.
Reference material.
http://www.addictinginfo.org/2012/03/12/wisconsin-voter-law-unconstitutional/
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/12/texas-voter-id-justice-department_n_1339004.html

First shots of the Civil War?


Does anyone who hasn't taken a course on the 1960's and/or Civil Rights movement know who Emmett Till is anymore? Just as a short refresher. Young master Till was visiting relatives in the deep south from Chicago, he wolf whistled at a white lady and taken by a lynch mob that night. He was barely recognizable when his body was found but his grieving mother insisted on an open casket to display the results of hate and white supremacy for the rest of society. Till wasn't the first, and certainly not the last, victim of violence in the south. Fast forward to 2012, when this kind of vigilante "justice" was supposed to be ancient history, and another young black man was murdered. Trayvon Martin was just walking home after getting a snack and was stalked and killed by a self-appointed neighborhood watch captain. The shooter, George Zimmerman, was not arrested because he claimed self-defense and under Florida's "Stand your ground" law, it is up to the state to prove he did not. What? GG Allin would be so proud, apparently murder has finally been legalized.
The problem with putting Till and Martin side by side is that beyond being black, murdered, and their murderers (so far) not facing any consequences there is little correlation. Till broke a strong and well-established southern more, and was murdered by a mob. This was long established tradition in the south, Till being a northerner was ignorant of it, but the point is that his murder was "extra-legal." Martin, by contrast, was a resident and broke no law or more, most importantly the law allowed what Zimmerman did. He stalked and killed Martin in daylight and in public, and suffered no consequences thusfar.
If you travel to my neck of the woods, however, there is a recent case with more similarity to Till's murder. Bo Morrisson was a 20 year old African-American who got drunk at a house party in a very white little community. Two strikes right? Even with no speculation on whether he wolf-whistled at any white girls at this party, the cops showed up to bust the party. Morrisson fled to the next door neighbor's enclosed porch to escape what would have been a pretty bad situation. And the homeowner, who still hasn't been identified, went onto the porch and shot him. Morrisson broke laws and mores by getting drunk at that party, then broke more of each by hiding on the porch. His murderer broke none. The evil twin of the "Stand your ground" law is called the "Castle doctrine" and says deadly force can be used to defend your family and property.
Dumb kids are gonna be dumb kids no matter where or when, but does being a dumbass warrant a death sentence by private individuals, "just because?" Zimmerman, Martin's murderer, hasn't exactly won much public support. But "the homeowner" who gunned down Morrisson in the middle of the night for being on his porch? Holy Moly has there been an outpouring of support for him. A simple smell test can tell you a lot about what these murders were about. Imagine it was a white kid gunned down on a black homeowner's porch. Perhaps some of the emminantly reasonable objections to this scenario would go like this: "Did the homeowner really have to kill this kid?" "This is not what the castle doctrine was intended for?" "Couldn't the homeowner have retreated inside his house behind a locked door and called the cops?" Unfortunately, this is not what happened.
So far, this is what passes for support for george zimmerman:

War is Peace, Freedom is Slavery, Ignorance is Strength.
I pray that Civil War is not imminent, but if it is, the legalization of murdering black kids should probably be considered it's Dred Scott decision.
GG would be proud that this society has become just as sick as him.

A few reference pieces, you figure them out. I know I can't remember why they are here.

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/22/opinion/collins-pity-the-poor-gun-lobby.html?_r=1&src=tp&smid=fb-share
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/22/opinion/shot-to-death-in-florida.html?src=tp&smid=fb-share
http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2012/03/21/do-stand-your-ground-laws-encourage-vigilantes/?ref=opinion
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/22/opinion/kristof-politics-odors-and-soap.html
http://onmilwaukee.com/living/articles/concealedcarrycastlelaws.html?29675
http://www.wisn.com/download/2012/0321/30733454.pdf

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Thomas Frank to the rescue

I was having a pretty lousy day until running into this ode to the deranged teabaggers by my favorite recovering historian.
I don't believe I've ever just cut and pasted an entire article before, but I kept all the source material so hopefully the thought police won't jump through my window tonight.
Originally posted at TomDispatch.

Pity the Quarter-Billionaire
Take a Ride on the RINO in 2012

By Thomas Frank
Dear Tea Party Movement,
For the last few months, the world has been fascinated by your frenzied search for a presidential candidate who is not Mitt Romney. We know that you find the man inauthentic and that you have buoyed up a string of anti-Mitts in the Iowa polling -- Michele Bachmann, Rick Perry, Herman Cain, Newt Gingrich -- buffoons all, preposterous figures whom you have rightfully changed your minds about as soon as you got to know them.
It was quite a spectacle, your quest for the non-Romney -- and I think we all know why you undertook it. In ways that matter, Romney is clearly a problem for you. His views on abortion, for example, change with the winds. Ditto, gay rights. He designed the Massachusetts health insurance system that was the model for Obamacare. And he’s even said that he approved of the TARP bank bailout, the abomination that ignited the Tea Party uprising in the first place.
Grievous offenses all, I have no doubt. Still, my advice to you idealists of the right is this: get over it. Not for sell-out reasons like: Romney has the best chance of beating Obama. No. You should get behind the charging Massachusetts RINO (your favorite term for a Republican-In-Name-Only sellout type) because, in a certain paradoxical way, he may turn out to be the truest of all the candidates to the spirit of your movement.
After all, given everything you represent, why wouldn’t you line up behind this quarter-billionaire who’s calling for just a little human love and sympathy for billionaires? I’m sure you already understand me perfectly well, but just to be certain, let me make the case.
The Gimme Candidate of 2012
Start with those issues where Romney’s positions so offend the sensibilities of you Robespierre Republicans. First, of course, the social issues. If nothing else, you in the Tea Party movement have spent the last three years teaching Americans that they no longer matter -- not when we’re supposedly in a battle for the very soul of capitalism.
And here comes Mitt Romney, the soul of American capitalism in the flesh. Look back over his career as a predator drone at Bain Capital: Isn’t it the exact sort of background you always insist politicians ought to have? Isn’t it the sort of titanic enterprise for which you lust, as you wave your copy of Atlas Shrugged in the air?
You accuse the former Massachusetts governor of opportunism, but from where I stand, the bad faith is all on your side. What offends you about Romney’s Massachusetts healthcare plan, for example, isn’t that it crushes human liberty, but that it provided the model for President Obama’s own healthcare overhaul, which you spent the last two years decrying as the deed of a power-grabbing socialist.
If the public ever learns about the Republican provenance of Obamacare -- and if Romney is the candidate, they most certainly will -- it will become obvious that your movement was not telling the truth about all that Kenyan Stalinist death-panel stuff. It is indeed a moment to fear, that day when the nation finds out that you were, ahem, exaggerating in your bullhorn pronouncements about the communist in the White House. Still, if the Tea Party movement is all about truth-telling and straight shooting, then you need to face it like a patriot.
And yes, Mitt Romney has also said that the bank bailouts of 2008-2009 were necessary, while you regard them as a mortal sin against free-market principles. (To his credit though, at least in your eyes, he was also a total hardliner about the auto industry bailouts, displaying the pointless meanness you seem to admire in nearly any other politician.) In truth, though, the candidate’s only offense on the bailout question was his candor. He merely admitted what should be obvious to any billionaire from a study of bank history: that conservatives have no problem doling out, or grabbing for, government money when the chips are down.
After all, President Herbert Hoover himself distributed bank bailouts in the early years of the Great Depression. Calvin Coolidge’s vice president, Charles Dawes, helped out in Hoover’s bailout operation, later changing hats and grabbing a big slice of the bailout pie for his own bank. Ronald Reagan’s administration rescued Continental Illinois from what was then the largest bank failure in our history.
Citibank’s market-worshiping CEO Walter Wriston begged for (and of course received) the assistance of big government when Citi needed it -- after making loans to the troubled Penn Central Railroad. And don’t forget, every single one of you is guilty of taking a government bailout any time you make a withdrawal from a bank that’s been rescued by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
The reason they -- I mean, you -- do these things should be as obvious as it is simple: “free market” has always been a high-minded way of saying “gimme,” and when the heat rises, the “market” is invariably replaced by more direct methods, like demanding bailouts from the government you hate. Banks get bailouts for the simple reason that they want bailouts and have the power to insist on them -- the same circumstances that got them deregulated in wave after wave in the Eighties, Nineties, and Aughts.
In this sense, Romney, who is loud and proud when it comes to the need for further deregulation, has actually been more consistent than you. He’s the gimme candidate of 2012 and so he should really be your guy.
Promethean Job Creators and Heroes of Venture Capital
You say Romney is an unprincipled faker. Fair enough -- he is. He’s so plastic he’s almost animatronic. But have you looked in the mirror recently? Aren’t you the ones who fall for it every time Fox News wheels out some Washington hack to confuse this or that corporate issue with the sacred cause of freedom or states rights or man’s inalienable right to mine uranium in his backyard? Aren’t you the ones who thought that Glenn Beck’s tears were markers of emotional sincerity? And for Pete’s sake, your populist Tea Party movement was actually launched from the floor of the Chicago Board of Trade!
I know, I know: for almost three years now you’ve dazzled the world with your proclamations that we’re being dragged into “tyranny,” that the country is being “destroyed,” that America needs to be “saved” -- and now here comes Mitt, with his fondness for workaday compromise, ruining your carefully contrived atmosphere of panic.
That must be disappointing, but don’t lose the faith! Give the man credit: he has tried. He’s no stranger to the core Tea Party myth of the noble businessman persecuted by big government. Indeed, at the Conservative Political Action Congress in 2009, he opened his talk as a stand-up comic this way: “I gotta get through this speech before federal officials come here and arrest me for practicing capitalism.”
Meanwhile, he has the perfect Tea Party sense of social class. A centimillionaire who made his pile as a venture capitalist, Romney has both deplored class warfare -- meaning, certain criticisms of Wall Street -- and practiced it, taunting President Obama as a modern version of Marie ("let them eat cake") Antoinette.
There’s no contradiction in any of this, either for him or you. When someone has made his way in life via academia, like the president, he is, of course, a snob, and part of the ruling elite. When, on the other hand, a person’s multi-millions were visited upon him by open-market actions directed from the C-suite, he is automatically a man of the people, a horny-handed son of toil. In fact, Romney takes this kind of market populism a step farther than you ordinarily dare: corporations, he has famously announced, are themselves people.
And keep in mind that, with Mitt Romney, venture capitalist, carrying your banner in 2012, you will finally get to submit your capsized vision of social class to the verdict of the people -- the actual flesh-and-blood people, that is, not the corporate “people” who make up the S&P 500. You will get to defend exactly the sort of “person” your movement has longed to defend since it was birthed by a CNBC reporter almost three years ago to the cheers of a bunch of derivatives traders in Chicago.
You will get to explain your peculiar conviction that the way to react to a gigantic slump brought on by frenzied finance is to unshackle Wall Street. You will get to line up behind a heroic businessman, like those rugged, resourceful fellows in the Ayn Rand novels you love. You will get to go into battle for the job creators, which is what all capitalists are, right? (Well, okay, maybe not the guys at Bain Capital, the particular outfit where Romney made his pile, but the theory is all that really matters, isn’t it?)
Indeed, your leadership cadre is already playing up the inevitable criticisms of Romney as a job decimator as a way of launching a grand debate about capitalism -- by which they mean, of course, freedom itself. When Newt Gingrich criticized Romney a few weeks ago for his career in private equity, the airwaves of your winger-tainment world exploded with outrage. “This is the kind of risk-taking, free-market capitalism that most people who call themselves conservatives applaud,” intoned Brit Hume on Fox News. If Newt had a problem with Bain’s operations, announced syndicated columnist Jonah Goldberg, “then Gingrich really doesn’t believe in capitalism at all.”
Washington Post columnist George Will declared that what Romney did in his venture capitalist days was an “essential social function,” that his company was “indispensable for wealth creation.” (Just whose wealth was being created he left discreetly undefined.) Yaron Brook, head of the Ayn Rand Center and a familiar figure at Tea Party events, is no fan of Romney’s, but he had this to say about Romney’s career: “private equity serves an incredibly important productive function in our economy… Private equity is in my view a heroic activity.”
“Heroic”: that’s exactly the word! In Romney we have finally found a quarter-billionaire to cry for. And so Suzy Welch, author and wife of Jack, appeared on Fox Business to wonder why Romney wasn’t defending himself aggressively against criticism of his business career. Romney, she announced, is “an American hero to people who believe in free enterprise, or he should be.”
And that combination of tragedy and heroism, my friends, is why you will soon be signing up for the Romney juggernaut. In him you will see the saintly victimhood of Sarah Palin melded with the Promethean job-creator who was the cult object of your 2010 efforts. Social issues be damned! Romney will ensure that we get the one thing that this country can’t do without on its path to hell: further deregulation of Wall Street.
The nation’s all-powerful elitist socialists will, of course, disagree, and you’ll have a field day, raging and weeping at the way they are going to set out to persecute this noble, wealth-creating soul.
Pity the billionaire: it will be a powerful rallying cry for 2012.
Yours in petulant individualism,
Tom
Thomas Frank is the author of the just-published Pity the Billionaire: The Hard-Times Swindle and the Unlikely Comeback of the Right (Metropolitan Books). He has also written The Wrecking Crew, What’s the Matter With Kansas? and several other abrasive volumes. He is the “Easy Chair” columnist for Harper’s Magazine and the founding editor of The Baffler.
Copyright 2012 Tom Frank
 At some future date I want to review Frank's latest book Pity the Billionaire, but I can't stop listening to it long enough to write. If you need a good book to listen to on your awful commute or job search, I highly recommend getting the audio version, read by the author.

Monday, March 19, 2012

The Framing Wars

Jill Klausen posted this helpful guide to not stepping into reactionary boobytraps this election season. I don't know if I am just especially gloomy this morning or resenting idealistic liberals who reflexively say that understanding framing drops "us" to the republican level of barbarism. Perhaps that is not the appropriate word, barbarism implies taking what you want by force. Many aspects of movement conservatism approach barbarism, such as vote-rigging, voter suppression, deceit and misdirection, and simply unleashing the cops to beat protesters, etc. But manipulation of language is more of an exercise in demogaugery than barbarism, so perhaps we can settle on calling republican framing simply an extraordinary program of propaganda on a particularly insidious level.
Klausen summarizes the problem this way: "Democrats have failed to speak in a language strong enough to rebut Republicans who have defined who we are and what we want, in a way that doesn't even remotely reflect an iota of the truth, and instantly conjures up the negative in the mind of the listener." Part of liberal/progressive failure is simple intellectual laziness, trying to speak in terms that play right into republican boobytraps. More insidious is the attitude of idealists such as the philosophy professor I loaned George Lakoff's book Don't think of an Elephant. Super Dave returned it to me the next day (it is a short book) and said, "very interesting, but if we go this route we will be as bad as the conservatives." Super Dave is a liberal, through and through, I mean by this that he hangs on to Enlightenment thinking. Further, that he ascribes to an earlier liberalism epitomized by John Dewey, that all people have the capacity to critically think about events and evaluate them rationally. Dewey argued through his long career that education was the key to building a better society and combined with the reform of institutions would yield a humane and just world.
I honestly and truly respect Super Dave and John Dewey, I wish their ideas were universally valid. But as an historian, I understand too well that beyond a point far from universality people simply are not rational and not equally capable of critical thought. And in any case, we live in a world that prizes irrationality and refuses to allow everyone the opportunity and access to the education necessary for training your mind. Dewey's great antagonist on this idealism was the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr. Niebuhr had a great understanding of Christianity (the good kind, not rick santorum's brand) as well as history and used it to formulate a philosophy of realism that understood the frailty of human nature but sought to use it to build a more just society in spite of human proclivities to injustice.
Though I am far from a Niebuhrian expert, I argue that he would have fully supported the use of framing. Not to manipulate people, but to empower them. Niebuhr argued that selflessness was good, selfishness was sinful and like Lakoff, good people must activate the better angels of selflessness and empathy while not discounting the power of self-interest in service to justice. To illustrate, Niebuhr wrote a book called The Children of Light and The Children of Darkness as a defense of democracy and pluralism. The Children of Darkness (or of This World as in the Bible) are wise but know no law beyond their self-interest, the Children of Light are foolish but reach beyond themselves to seek justice for all humanity. Sound familiar at all? Niebuhr also had some interesting things to say about group morality that applied well to the conservative tribalism in contemporary America. Moral Man and Immoral Society posited the idea that individuals could be selfless but group identity by individuals often leads to immoral actions by organizations and institutions. Niebuhr suggested that even patriotism, the selfless love of country, could be turned to immoral ends by both individuals and leaders.
Niebuhr would understand that if Children of Darkness used framing to manipulate people into supporting the selfish ends of the CoD, the Children of Light must use framing in the service of selfless ends for the achievment of justice. But isn't this "just as bad" you may ask? In a way yes, but Niebuhr had an explanation for this as well, Irony. He argued that a pathetic situation, such as masses of working people voting against their self-interest by voting republican, illicited pity. A truly evil situation where republicans use wedge issues and framing to "manufacture consent" for their destructive policies, illicts contempt. But the ironic situation is one in which evil means are used for just or good purposes. Thus, during the Cold War Niebuhr argued the irony of American nuclear arms kept in readiness for use to keep the peace even though their actual use would destroy the world.
Now, Super Dave and other idealists would probably argue that Demosthenes and Aristotle did not need framing to pursuade their audiences. Using framing in response to republican propaganda undermines democracy and insults the intelligence of the people. To this I unfortunately have to point to the 2010 midterm elections, not ancient history. Two words, "death panels" and fierce desire to shamelessly promote themselves allowed the reactionary base of the gop to reinvent itself as the tea party (itself a shameless use of framing) to fire up and scare people who rationally would know better to the polls. Thus ensuring that the next two years at least will and have been about putting the needs of conservatives far, far ahead of what is best for the nation and obstructing rationalism as an end unto itself.
Any strategy to reclaim America for the Children of Light must include the use of framing issues on progressive terms. Without activating frames favorable for empathy and justice in the electorate, all the best intentions of the foolish Children of Light are buried under an avalanche of fear, hate, superstition, and selfishness.