Showing posts with label intro to politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intro to politics. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 26, 2016

Voting your conscience

I would like to stake a position about this issue that the Bernie or bust crowd is not going to like. Voting in the general election, while an individual right, is a public responsibility and not just a personal choice. The time to build a movement, plan a revolution, organize like-minds into a coherent vision for the future; that time is between elections. We are stuck with the hodge podge mashup of precedent, tradition, and the push-pull of various interest groups in the present. Voting your conscience sounds good, but like so many sound byte, bumper sticker slogans used by the Right, it means less than nothing. In fact, treating your vote like your virginity, only to be surrendered to the perfect candidate, is actually surrendering the nation and yourself to the forces of darkness. Anyone throwing a purity tantrum now, when the country actually has a chance at a Democratic successor to the presidency, is acting like a child.

I don't care how many fussy dilettantes unlike my page or send nasty emails, you have had eight years to build an alternative to the Democratic establishment, and you didn't. It is time to grow up and realize that the establishment was here before you and I were and there's no silver bullet to destroy it. Do you think progressive taxation, minimum wage laws, Social Security, Medicare/Medicaid, anti-trust laws, the National Labor Relations Board, workman's compensation, and all the rest happened overnight or easily? No, liberal reform has always been a work in progress. Vote for Bernie in the primary, work for his campaign, protest real injustice, and work to persuade people to take an interest in issues that matter. But have a little dignity, show some humility, and for crying out loud listen to yourselves. Have the Democrats been so awful for the past eight years that you are willing to surrender the presidency to Donald Trump or Ted Cruz because you believe the three decade smear campaign against Hillary Clinton?

I was on the fence about this Bernie or bust business until I got a chance to hear some of them call in to the Brad cast recently. Up to that time I had only seen a few dingbats write about how they will never vote for Hillary Clinton if she is the Democratic nominee. They never come across as being particularly knowledgeable or wise, but in print the anger and screaming doesn't come through. So now I know that the idiot tea party paranoid style is not just on the extreme right. When I heard these people yelling and ranting about Hillary, it became clear that tea baggers are not the only gullible authoritarian followers out there.

Before you turn up your nose and dismiss me as part of the establishment or a sell out or whatever, I did vote for Bernie Sanders in the primary. I respect his integrity, his positions on issues that matter to me, and I respect him as a man of the people. However, you people out there, who were all in for the ReLOVEution or whatever that was for Ron Paul. You who stood with Rand Paul because President Obama is worse that Bush; and you who are now claiming that the only thing you can do in good conscience if Bernie doesn't win the nomination of a party he still does not belong to is to stay home and pout or vote third party, are not worthy of any respect. I dealt with a lot of you in the Army, we called them blue falcons, the ones who refused to ever admit a mistake or something they did wrong, and were willing to let the whole unit be punished because they couldn't own up and take responsibility. Yes, if you could put aside your juvenile idealistic standards for the moment it would take to pull the lever for the socially responsible act of keeping a fascist like Trump or a theocrat like Cruz out of the White House there would be no problem. But you have to keep going on about this as though it is somehow noble to throw away a perfectly good chance at keeping momentum going for a progressive future. 

No, of course Hillary Clinton is not perfect and neither is the Democratic Party. Why? Because she is human, and the party is made up of humans. People who have flaws, people who have different views, different experience, and yes, different levels of involvement in the special interests and corrupting influences of money. No one in politics has exactly the same perspective, that is why we have parties. The objective is to get as many people's ideas as possible aggregated into as coherent a platform as possible. It is unfortunate that basic political science is not dropped into our political discourse very often. So rarely in fact, that when I tried Google searching for some of the ideas I studied many moons ago in poli sci 101 I could not find them so I'll have to paraphrase. Our electoral system is called single district plurality or first past the post, meaning that only the candidate with the greatest vote total wins. Therefore, rational office seekers coalesce into a mere two choices as close to the center as possible with one party going one way from that center and the other going the other way. The two party system, while sounding like the least number of choices outside of a one party dictatorship, actually presents the greatest choice in a winner take all election. The problem is that republican so-called conservatives have pulled that center further and further to the right, and then run candidates who start on the far right and only grudgingly move to moderate their stances and thereby increase their constituency. Democrats like Hillary Clinton start at the center and generally get pulled to the right. This is not a good situation I grant you, but threatening to pout and stay home is not going to help anyone but the Republican candidate. 

Right now, Bernie or bust people are nothing but lonely, alienated voices in the wilderness. You have no money, no organization, and no leverage; nothing really to offer. Screaming on social media or call in shows does nothing but alienate you further from people who actually have something to lose if a republican takes the White House. And that is why I'm saying that voting your conscience is a self-defeating fallacy. Make your voice heard constructively, build something, move the center in a more progressive direction. But simply screaming about how you will refuse to vote if your demands are not met will alienate you not only from the people you claim to be making your noble claim about defending but the Democratic Party as well.

Again, a personal campaign to make the political system more just, to fight for equality, and society more fair is best conducted between elections. The stakes are too high to pull this crap right now. The last eight years would have been a golden opportunity to organize all the people hurt by bush's wars and financial collapse, to educate people on why big changes were needed. That didn't happen, but there is no reason why you can't try again.

After the election, no matter who the Democratic nominee is. Patience, we can do this right. And it won't mean selling out, it just means being a team player. Aim lower, if the tea bag authoritarians can take over their local parties and put bible-thumping weirdos or monsters like this guy into office, imagine what we could do with good ideas. 

Tuesday, February 23, 2016

Election 2016: Opening Thoughts

One objective that this blog has developed is to make readers more skeptical and less gullible to the many distractions, misinformation, and outright lies perpetrated by political operatives. Education should be a universal value after all, should it not? You would be surprised how many people are simply not interested in learning more, improving themselves, or challenging information if it agrees with what they already believe. Is this where the dividing line should be drawn in our politics? Between the people who want to know more and improve themselves, versus the people who are content in their limited knowledge and want to force everyone else to freeze intellectually. It is a tragedy that the information superhighway accommodates too easily both of these.

The irony is thick when you consider that the Internet is one of the greatest technological developments of human history and a significant percentage of Americans use it to wall themselves off from anything that would challenge their views. Don't do that. Your computer or smartphone can answer any question you can think of, and most likely direct you to more sources of information where you can figure out new questions to ask. Much of our collected knowledge and wisdom out there waiting to be tapped and harnessed to your command. Sometimes you have to step back from your day to day routine and really consider what a fascinating time it is to be alive. Be curious. Be adventurous. But also, be cautious; and skeptical.

We humans have amazing qualities. We can use tools and remember the past; we can communicate with each other and our offspring, each individual is connected to their neighbors and the future in this way. The internet and all of its myriad portals are new tools that empower us to communicate and remember. But it also amplifies other qualities, such as that of deception, manipulation, domination, intimidation, exclusion, and unthinking obedience that are less useful. 

For example, when the first human tried using a stick to poke holes in the ground and plant food, he (or she) could gather more sustenance than the others who simply gathered nature produce. That person was able to feed themselves better than the others and was consequently able to have more children and live longer. Those children did not have to then spend time figuring out how to use a stick and could instead figure out how to make a better tool. In turn, that knowledge would spread until it was an entire tribe settling down to practice agriculture and take further steps forward in improving their techniques until they produced a surplus of food. When there is a surplus of food, some people can be freed from farming to spend time, energy, thought, and resources on new ways to help the tribe. Once that happens there is a division of labor, society is no longer equal and governing structures arise to regulate the relations of power. This is where politics is born. 

There will always be people who want to keep going, inventing new things, telling new stories, teaching and learning new ways to benefit society. And there will always be others who say "that's far enough," for some people change is just too much to bear. There are many reasons to oppose change or stand in the way of progress, it does not mean the same thing to all people. For another, going back to the idea of "where you sit determines where you stand" from the first post in this series, the division of labor and surplus creates opportunities for privilege, and change often threatens the privileged members of society. Luckily for those elites, many common people fear change out of reflex because of advanced age or lack of sophistication, intellect, curiosity, or imagination. The elite often have little trouble convincing a plurality or even majority of society to keep things the same, or at least change things very slowly and as skewed toward elite interest as possible. In the past the elite often took the form of land-holding warriors or priests and as such their words carried weight with the peasants, who feared for their lives and/or souls. Today, the elite often have power in the form of wealth and control over jobs, development, investment, etc. And especially control over media to sway public opinion towards the interests of that privileged few.

Whenever there is political conflict, it often takes the form described in the previous paragraph. Reformers, also known as Liberals or Progressives, put forward a new idea or invention and the privileged elite minority who happen to like their position in society thank you very much, resist the change with support among the uncurious and fearful commoners. In the past you would often find the peasants supporting the king against some middle-class force trying to change society. Today, things are far more complicated. But the conservative fear of change persists even in the United States of 2016. Subsequent entries to this series will explore these divisions and conflicts in greater detail. For now, take a look at the next politically-themed meme or article that shows up in your news feed with these ideas in mind. And try not to lose composure over the latest attempt by the cynical to make you afraid, because they want you to be afraid but it is very often in your best interest to remain rational. Until next time, good luck and keep exploring!

Friday, February 19, 2016

Election 2016: The Beginning

You may have heard somewhere that there will be an election in the United States to choose a new president. You also may know that you can cast a vote for a candidate for president, in addition you can vote for all sorts of other offices and there may even be issues called initiatives and referendums where you can directly vote for or against the passage of certain laws. No really, I am totally serious.

Now, before you click away because it sounds like I'm insulting your intelligence, hear me out. I'm writing it this way because there are a lot of people out there who have not voted before, or do not understand the extremely daunting system and issues that come with it. You may be considering participating this time and not know where to start. It is nothing to worry about, though they may not admit it, everyone starts from zero when it comes to voting and civic participation. The problem it seems, is who is available when you do want to take that first step? Sure, we are taught in K-12 but it often is not reinforced or taught in a way that actually makes you want to get involved with politics, or even feel that the abstract lessons are applicable to real life. Maybe it wasn't cool enough or you were too focused on preparing for college or other post-high school plans. It is never too late to get involved, to learn, to vote, to reach out to others. Doing something is better than doing nothing, and if you are reading this then it is likely that you want to do something. I can try to help, and I want to help, but in the end it is up to you.

The first thing to try and keep in mind is that this is a very big country with over three hundred million people living in it. Each one has a past and a future, comes from different areas of life, and therefore has different ideas about how this country should be run. "Where you sit goes a long way towards where you stand" as one person I met put it. He meant that if you are in management you should always vote against any measure or candidate who proposes to raise standards of living for working people. In that case it was the battle over the right of government workers in the state of Wisconsin to organize in unions. Does that sound fair to you? Would you support someone who said they were going to make your life harder and your job less secure? Lots of people who stood to gain nothing from it did in fact vote for Scott Walker. And lots of them now are indeed less secure. They were not all in management, so why did they vote against their own interest? Well, this is why American politics is so hard to understand.

If you turn on the news or pick up a newspaper, or more likely see an article shared by a friend or coworker on social media you are likely to be catching a story in the middle of it. And just like catching a movie in the middle, it can be really confusing. Also unfortunate is that most political writers, whether bloggers like me up to the often grossly overpaid elites on TV or in print, are writing for an audience "in the know." There is very little space dedicated to helping people understand politics and government. Lots of words get thrown around that are unfamiliar to someone just starting out. It can be a huge turn off, and I totally understand. I was there too once and grew awfully frustrated on several occasions, but I can be really stubborn when I want to figure something out so I kept at it. By the time I went to college I could at least say I knew what questions I wanted to ask.

I am a lot more interested in building better citizens than simply persuading you to vote a certain way. You could just google up a government website telling you how to register to vote. Or visit your local Democratic or Republican Party office. The volunteers or workers there will probably be happy to help you vote, but voting is not all there is to good citizenship. We live in crazy times, dangerous and exciting. We have more than eight months to figure things out. Let's get started!