Showing posts with label The Daily Banter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Daily Banter. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 30, 2017

From Reagan to Trump

Another day in the crisis of American democracy. Where are we in this drama so far? Robert Reich posted this video today and does a good job summarizing at least part of the problem. How many hoops do we have to jump through to finally nail the trump/Russia treason down? Will it ever happen? Will it be sudden and unexpected or long and drawn out? Will the con man simply resign after pardoning everyone he can or will he have to be arrested and dragged out? At this point no one knows for sure but real damage is done every day. Let's be honest, despite some bright shining moments, mainstream corporate media has been absolutely atrocious in dealing with republican sedition for a long time. And today they seem to feel as though they cannot comment on each new day's atrocities without lamenting how pure and patriotic past republican presidents were. It is expected on cable or broadcast news to always try to balance and treat liars as though they have something worth our time to say. At every step the constitutionally-enshrined protectors of our republic pull punches, treat lightly, fail to challenge the lies, reach for something, anything that the Democrats have done to claim a false equivalence, and give an undeserved deference to some of the greatest villains our society has produced.

Democrats then bring butter knives to fight against the mechanized armor division that the republicans have spent so many years building. One of their worst offenses is appealing to the center and for unity, George Lakoff has spent years trying to convince Democrats and Progressives to stop playing into authoritarian hands in this fruitless endeavor. There is no "Center" where the left and the right meet and people could agree to rational solutions to real problems. There isn't even a spectrum or sliding scale of left to right according to Lakoff, but that one is kind of tough to get our heads around after so many years of hearing about that spectrum. So the piece I want to look at today is Vice President Joe Biden's call for the rest of us to reject doughfacedonny's crap and be the good nation we aspire to be. It is good, he hits all the right notes of keeping and building on the moral conscience that elected he and President Obama, and rejecting the hate and racism that donny has dredged up. The only problem is that he doesn't call out donny by name, a small one for sure as I can't even use his name nor put the title of "president" in front of it. Brother Charlie Pierce put it well, "say his name when you denounce his bigotry", though he was addressing the crocodile tear-shedding republicans who mouthed words to the effect of "this will not do donny." But it is the same product.

As evidenced by the naming of neo-nazi marchers in Charlottesville and their subsequent firing, it is effective. It is personal, the so-called alt right and their fellow republican base voters WANT US DEAD, so shaming and shining a spotlight on individuals is the right thing to do. It has to be made so toxic to even be associated with nazis that republicans can't get away with ambiguous statements like what Lyin' Ryan, the zombie-eyed granny starver from the state of Wisconsin made after donny tried to falsely equate "many sides" for violence by broadly generalizing about all hate and all bigotry is bad. No, we're talking about what actually happened, real people with real names who gathered together to support monuments to confederate traitors, the neo-nazis whose antecedents nearly succeeded in exterminating all of the Jews in Europe. It was a big step for Vice President Biden to actually refer to the current president, not some generalization, even if he didn't say the name. Unlike the Democratic Party's latest slogan of "a better deal" that doesn't even acknowledge the existence of an opposition party that made it this bad for regular Americans and constantly try to make it worse. Of course the better deal platform was a response to the fact that the Democrats really don't stand for anything, even if Progressives want to believe and continue to work in the direction of equality, social and economic justice etc., as polls reported in July.

Really, we can walk and chew gum at the same time. If you act as though current conditions are something that just happened, like a bolt of lightning hitting your home, instead of something that was done deliberately as in a burglar stealing everything before burning it down, then yes people are going to believe that you don't stand for anything. It makes the current state of the union to be fate, instead of something that was consciously made over decades. Which brings me to the response to Biden's article from Ben Cohen of The Daily Banter. Now I don't mean to single Ben out or come down on him too hard, his heart is in the right place and I generally support his positions. And I hear the same sort of thing from his colleague at the banter, Bob Cesca, and from the Stephanie Miller show to name two examples. The problem is letting past republicans off the hook because they weren't the unbelievable shit show that doughfacedonny has been.

Ben starts his analysis like this:
 Whatever you might think of Joe Biden and his politics, he never sought to divide Americans or appeal to their hate. Biden didn’t use minorities as scapegoats, insult women or deride allies, and while he wasn’t perfect, Biden was a man of dignity who always appealed to our better nature.
Why the weasel words? Who do you think this kind of appeal will win over? People aren't perfect, there's no reason to state this. And even the comparison of donny's antics to what Biden stood for in office is ridiculous, that's not the bar of statesmanship. Lakoff would point out that there's no reason to qualify Biden or his politics, that simply gives the right ammunition. And it deactivates the frame of what he's talking about, nothing that is happening today has anything to do with Joe Biden.

Then the gut punch that sucks all the wind out of any Progressive impact Ben Cohen could have with this article:
I’m not a fan of Ronald Reagan and completely disagree with his politics, but he did not appeal to hate while in office. He did not vilify immigrants, demean women, or equate Neo-Nazis with anti-fascist protesters. This is why many conservatives and almost all liberals recognize the danger in Donald Trump. This isn’t so much about policy, it’s about politics and the devastating effect divisive language and demagoguery has on the psyche of a nation.
First, what the hell does any of this have to do with Reagan? Why bring him up? That just activates the frame of divinity surrounding Reagan that obviously liberals give some credence to as well. Trying to negate a frame by invoking a supposed "good conservative" only reinforces it. And you might want to check with an actual Reagan scholar like Rick Perlstein before making these claims. Reagan began his presidential campaign in Philadelphia, Mississippi by talking "states' rights" clearly dog whistling his continuation of Nixon's southern strategy. Then as president he visited the nazi cemetery at Bitburg despite strong opposition from Jewish groups. What about the lying stories about "welfare queens", did those not demean women? Reagan was really hot to "reduce labor costs" (i.e. Your Pay) by breaking unions and deregulating everything, the undocumented immigrant amnesty was a big part of that and contributed to the anti-immigrant backlash today.

So why commit an unforced error like this? To achieve some sort of artificial balance? Appeal to the brain dead reprogrammable meat sacks that still support donny? Please stop doing this, anyone on the left. I have seen enough sentiments to "George W. Bush is so happy he's not the worst president in history" that I want to tear my own tentacles off. This accomplishes nothing positive and only legitimizes past republican crimes against the American people. I know so many activists and writers are desperately trying to break the cycle of "normalizing" Trump, but letting everyone from Nixon to Bill Kristol off the hook for the harm they did to discourse and society isn't the way to go.

It really has been an almost straight line of crimes from Reagan to Trump, each successive republican raised the bar of awfulness to where we are actually seeing democracy fade away and racism become just another political opinion. They are different only by degrees, not in kind. There is no set goal, Reagan most likely never thought he was pointing us in the direction of a fascist dictatorship, but his actions and the words and deeds of subsequent republicans have led us to this point. Stop falling for it!

Sunday, February 26, 2017

RIP Chez Pazienza

The Resistance lost a powerful voice yesterday. I woke up to read Bob Cesca's post that his partner in podcasting, and my friend, Chez Pazienza passed away last night. No one has said how so far and he was only 47. This is the definition of not fair, and where lots of people will throw around phrases like "no justice, too soon, unbelievable," and so on. As internet social circles go though, I considered him a real friend. I could send him messages and he would reply as though I was a real person and not some anonymous collection of 1s and 0s in the Aether. I miss him already.

Far more eloquent and passionate writers than I have already weighed in on Facebook about Chez' passing. I simply want to be part of the chorus. How can a nobody like me expect to add something original or moving? I was just honored to be a tiny junior fanboy of both Bob and Chez, Listening to them always felt like I was the freshman sort of on the periphery of the cool seniors' table. But instead of making fun of or belittling me when I asked a question or had something I wanted to share Chez listened and thoughtfully responded. That was the kind of guy he was, though he would overgeneralize about how stupid other (republican) people were, one on one respect and common courtesy were the rule for Chez.

Too soon, for sure. I listened and read each of Chez' laments for all the recent passing of artists who made such an impact on and enriched our lives. I never thought for a second that he would be joining them. No justice, oh man oh man. If Chez divided the world into the good guys and the bad guys, as I suspect he really did in a way reminiscent of the great theologian Reinhold Niebuhr whom I once compared him to, then our team is down so many starters and quality backups while the bad guys are all still sitting pretty and sucking the life out of everyone.

Hearing the news this morning made me immediately think of Hunter S. Thompson, not that I have any reason to believe it was suicide or that Chez really had much in common with the Gonzo legend. But Thompson fought the good fight against Richard Milhous Nixon, he lived through Reagan and watched the wave of enlightenment crest in the '60s and steadily recede. Finally, in the wake of the reelection (ho ho) of George W. Bush he had finally had enough and exercised the option of cashing in his chips. Chez experienced 9/11 at a deeply personal level and dedicated a good portion of his life fighting back at those who exploited the tragedy of that day. It would not surprise me in the least to find out that the triumph of cartoon fascism broke his heart.

I re-titled this blog a while back because gloominess just wasn't appropriate, besides I felt Chez had the market on gloominess kind of cornered. What I thought at the time was how much justice and fairness really are human constructs, the universe could give less than a warm squirt of piss what happens to any of us. Tentacles of course are popularly associated with the cosmic horror of H.P. Lovecraft. And the only way to make sense of Chez' passing without delving into conspiracy, which he would have absolutely hated, is to accept that the universe is utterly indifferent. We care that he is gone; but the stars don't.

Not to be sentimental pseudo-religious because I know he'd hate that too, but I hope that Chez is up in a heaven of his liking, hanging out with Bowie and Prince, and all the others he respected and admired who preceded him there. Your battle is over Deux Ex Malcontent, the rest of us will carry on. The good fight was worth fighting when Chez was on Earth and he fought it well; it remains the good fight today and everyday hereafter it will be worth it.


Tuesday, August 25, 2015

Eugenics and The Big Lie

Ben Carson, Republican candidate for president and retired neurosurgeon, appeared on ABC News to spread another historical inversion about Eugenics and Margaret Sanger. Bob Cesca called out the good doctor's inaccuracies and pointed out that these crazy ideas come straight out of the fevered imagination of agent provocateur and conspiracy theorist Alex Jones. Cesca pointed out that the quote from Sanger was grossly taken out of context and the only other piece of evidence ever presented by the glossy-eyed true believers of this mythology is a completely doctored map manufactured by a propaganda outfit purporting to show that Planned Parenthood clinics are largely sited in predominantly black neighborhoods. These falsehoods are also exposed by a study from FactCheck.org already in 2011 when they were uttered by the last GOP Forkboy Herman Cain. The reason for all these attacks on Planned Parenthood are simple, PP and Margaret Sanger were the "good guys" in Eugenics history, and need to be destroyed as part of the larger war on women declared by the fascist right.

Ideology is a set of guiding ideas that inform the actions and beliefs of adherents. Ideological conflict can occur within and between these ideas, which compete to drive politics and government policy. The free market fundamentalism guiding government and corporate policy in the United States is an ideology that has been internalized to such a degree that it has lost it's identity as one of many guiding sets of ideas, much to the detriment of living things in this country and on Earth. It has many commonalities with Eugenics' competing ideology, Social Darwinism. As Planned Parenthood represents the positive side of Eugenics and was supported by many Progressives at the turn of the century as well as today, it is naturally an enemy that must be destroyed. Contraception, family planning, and yes, even abortion were liberal in that they empower individuals at the expense of elites. However much family planning empowers elites as well, working-class people gain a great deal from controlling the size and composition of their families. Children in Progressive Era America were coming to be seen as economic liabilities as many families crammed into urban tenements and no longer worked their own land. As such, having control over the number of mouths to feed was a positive for parents as well as a social good in itself.

To backtrack a little, Eugenics was Greek for "good in birth" and was coined as a name for certain principles by Sir Francis Galton, the British scientist who coalesced many ideas about genetics and evolution into this ideology. In short, Galton was influenced by his distant cousin, Charles Darwin, about natural selection and wanted to improve humanity through artificial selection. Galton was not exactly a heroic character, his own childless marriage led him to the hypothesis that aristocratic women failed to produce enough offspring from husbands of genius on their own and needed to be compelled in some way to have larger families and thereby increase intelligence in society. Conversely, imbeciles should be prevented from marrying and reproducing, thereby improving the race through guided breeding.

Two things can be taken away from this foundation story. First is that these "negative" eugenicists were elitist, they would use the power of the state to enforce who can have children and how many. Sanger and other "positive" eugenicists would use the power of the state to improve sanitation, medical care, the distribution of milk, education about hygiene and so on, but depend on the power of self-interest for people to voluntarily use contraception to limit the size of their families. Negative eugenicists were often progressives but in elite positions like doctors, prison wardens, social workers and were therefore used to making decisions for other people. In the US eugenics was less concerned with encouraging the strong and intelligent to have more children but much more concerned with stopping the "feeble-minded" from reproducing. And their methods were confined mostly to wards of the state, segregating by sex in mental asylums and prisons, prohibiting marriage between the indigent, and ultimately sterilization of social work cases that could be deemed "degenerate." After all, eugenics was concerned with improving the (white) race and arresting degeneration in white people, a prevalent idea that many in the lower classes were actually de-evolving after some golden age of enlightened superiority. Actually much of the supposed degeneration was caused by problems in the environment, not genetics, from poor working conditions to crowded living spaces.

I was as surprised as anyone after doing research that historic eugenics in the US and English-speaking world was not concerned with eradicating the inferior races. In every instance I found, eugenic sterilization and segregation measures were about purging degeneracy among white people, they didn't care about African-Americans or other races. Why would one expend energy studying or "improving" other races that you were supposedly competing with? In any case, eugenic ideas had a very difficult time gaining hold in "backward" areas of the US like the South because of entrenched religion. Eugenic sterilization did occur in the South but it was limited compared to a "frontier" area like California, which as a newer area of the US lacked the strong traditions that opposed new-fangled ideas like evolution or engineered breeding.

So when Ben Carson or anyone carrying water for Alex Jones tries to project Nazi holocaust images onto historical eugenics in the US, they are selling a big lie. The contradictions of pitching this idea that Planned Parenthood is carrying out an extermination of the African-American community to the Republican base that frequently complains about the very existence of African-Americans is mind-boggling. It must take an enormous amount of ideological discipline to believe that an under-funded organization can carry out such a feat through the voluntary actions of individual patients. But contradictions are at the heart of anyone claiming to be "pro-life" yet supports the death penalty, mass incarceration, police brutality, the proliferation of firearms, "stand your ground" and the republican enthusiasm for endless war. It is a good example of the compartmentalized thinking from right wing authoritarian followers that they can separate these contradictory ideas.

Belief in the zombie lie that Planned Parenthood targets blacks for extermination while ignoring actual history is strong evidence that ideology trumps facts in the minds of partisans. What exactly do Forkboys like Dr. Carson and Mr. Cain achieve through this particular lie?

For further reading




Horwitz, Howard. “Always with Us.” American Literary History 10 (1998): 317-334.

Klausen, Susanne. “’For the Sake of the Race:’ Eugenic Discourses of Feeblemindedness and               Motherhood in the South African Medical Record, 1903-1926.” Journal of Southern                   African Studies 23 (1997): 27-50.

Nye, Robert. “The Rise and Fall of the Eugenics Empire: Recent Perspectives on the Impact of Biomedical Thought in Modern Society.” The Historical Journal 36 (1993): 687-700.

Sandall, Roger “Sir Francis Galton and the Roots of Eugenics.” Society 45 (2008): 170-176.


Soloway, Richard. “Counting the Degenerates: The Statistics of Race Deterioration in Edwardian           England.” Journal of Contemporary History 17 (1982): 137-164.

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

David Brooks and the Jumping of Sharks.

It is not every day that a genuine social problem enters the American political discourse. In the 1930s the public and the government discovered that unregulated capitalism and wild financial speculation with depositor's money was a bad thing, and took great steps to rein in excesses. In the 1960s the public similarly decided it was time for the South to grow up and start treating African Americans like human beings. In the 1970s popular pressure encouraged Richard Nixon of all people to work with other Republicans, and Democrats to form the Environmental Protection Agency and other laws to curb pollution. Sometimes the stars align, critical mass forms and what was once simply discussion among intellectuals turns into actual policy with strong popular support. Occasionally we get it really wrong, drugs and terrorism come to mind, but there are real world examples when democracy functions and good policies emerge to combat social problems.

We may be approaching this point on income inequality. Slowly, belatedly, and against incredible opposition it is finally reaching the broad public mind that maybe having 85 people with the same wealth as the bottom half of the human race is not conducive to a good situation. Oxfam's executive director put it rather bluntly:
Without a concerted effort to tackle inequality, the cascade of privilege and of disadvantage will continue down the generations. We will soon live in a world where equality of opportunity is just a dream. In too many countries economic growth already amounts to little more than a ‘winner takes all’ windfall for the richest.
If you are reading this post I probably do not need to spend more time making the case that inequality of wealth and income are bad for most people, or society in general. But briefly, when too much wealth is concentrated at the top, the rich can bid the price of necessities up and out of reach for the rest of us. They can also corrupt the political process with money and when all else fails hire strong men with guns to intimidate, beat up, or kill anyone who disagrees.

Leaders shape opinion to some degree in any situation. During the American Revolution pamphlets written by very smart men were passed around and discussed at taverns all over the colonies. Some ideas were accepted, others rejected, and still more changed through debate and compromise. While you may be hard-pressed to find serious political discussion in American watering holes today, this process still exists. And here is where David Brooks enters, finally. I know I'm a little tardy in writing about a column from January 16th and I apologize but this is a debate long overdue in America and is an ongoing discussion that will likely last longer than a few news cycles. In short, this New York Times Op-Ed writer who makes an ungainly number of appearances on Sunday talk shows to represent the "respectable" conservative position is not the opinion leader we need right now.

In The Inequality Problem Brooks leverages every ounce of his mainstream respectability to misdirect and mislead his readers on the title subject. From the first line: "Suddenly the whole world is talking about income inequality." Brooks turns reality on it's head. No Davey, this did not happen "suddenly," nor is inequality "lump[ing] together different issues that are not especially related." You may recall the champion of private equity and GOP standard-bearer Mitt Romney stating that inequality is something people should discuss only in private, and in dimly-lit rooms. Or that a few protestors made a little noise in Seattle during the WTO's 1999 meeting in that city to voice their concerns that a few unelected corporations should not be able to reorder society along plutocratic lines. Thank goodness George W. Bush came along to put inequality on the back burner by making war, torture, wire-tapping, and general tyrannical behavior the prime concerns of activists, but that does not mean inequality somehow disappeared from 2001 to today.

As the blogger Driftglass succinctly put it:
For the record, without too much effort, any competent citizen from Paul Krugman to my sainted mother can incinerate Mr. Brooks' increasingly frantic and transparent attempt to decouple 30 years of aggressively pro-plutocrat, anti-labor, anti-equality policies of the Right from any discussion of income inequality...
 
...which is so much of out mainstream is devoted to keeping fragile Conservatives like Mr. Brooks as carefully protected and climate-controlled as any hothouse orchid, and the Hell away from competent citizens. [emphasis mine]
Driftglass further ridicules the pompous and insulated Brooks' argument as irrelevant misdirection by summarizing the rest of The Inequality Problem as " Look over here!  Look over here! -- please for God's sake lets get back to talking about unwed teenage mothers and stuff." Yup, that is pretty much all he has, roll out the usual "blame the victim" tripe that poor people are poor because they are lazy and spend too much time having unprotected, out of wedlock sex. Ben Cohen at The Daily Banter also summarized Brooks' position as "divid[ing] the world into responsible rich people and irresponsible poor people, and postulates that inequality has nothing to do with the wealthy rigging the economy to maintain their wealth, but more to do with failed policies towards poor people, who just breed and won’t work." Since it is poor peoples' own fault, raising the minimum wage or other policies will not help and the responsible aristocrats like Brooks can wave it away without evidence. David Brooks represents the respectable mainstream arm of the conservative media complex, like his fellow shills for the rich on fox news or talk radio he is well paid to muddy the waters and present reasonable doubt against common sense. Leave no stone unturned, no rhetorical device unused, and no logical fallacy unfoisted to protect profit margins.

Cohen cites a further analysis and refutation of the "respectable" position by Robert Reich, an intellectual who combines empathy, erudition, education, with the empirically obvious plight of the increasingly poor working class of America. After reciting well-established facts about inequality, Professor Reich hits on the biggest of the gaping holes in Brooks' argument. In a display of stunning ignorance, Brooks states without irony that we cannot allow class-consciousness enter the debate on income inequality, because: "America has always done better, liberals have always done better, when we are all focused on opportunity and mobility, not inequality, on individual and family aspiration, not class-consciousness." In other words, yes the poor are a problem but talking about inequality "needlessly polarizes the debate [emphasis in original]" Not to put too fine a point on it, but has Brooks ever left his comfy little bubble? America is utterly, and intractably, polarized. For crying out loud, there are people freaking out that Coke ran an ad where America the beautiful was sung in languages other than English. Influential conservatives regularly call for impeachment and armed rebellion against a twice elected president. Everything from chicken sandwiches to Duck Dynasty has been thoroughly politicized. If ever Noam Chomsky's thesis that only one side is waging the class war was made apparent, this is it.

Ben Cohen followed up his analysis of David Brooks and whether conservatives really hate the poor by presenting, with referencing links and context, five examples of Brooks' unending class-consciousness and polarizing language in the defense of the rich. In this debate, we have great examples of confusing correlation and causation, lies of omission, framing devices, and wealth apologia. The debate on income inequality also shows how the discussions which used to be held in taverns have migrated to cyberspace. Not a moment too soon has the internet allowed the commoners to challenge the lords and their heralds. This might be our last chance to have this debate too, as well as our last chance to preserve some small space for popular participation in the business of state.

"Jumping the shark" has become a euphemism for television programs that have run out of ideas. It refers to an episode of Happy Days when Fonzie proved once again to be the coolest guy around by water skiing and jumping over shark infested waters, or something to that effect. It was too much for the audience and most people point to that moment of Fonzie in the air wearing his leather jacket and swim trunks as when Happy Days went over the edge of cool. One can only hope that David Brooks' breathless defense of wealth and concurrent condemnation of the poor has finally jumped the shark on our indefensible system of corporate personhood and human commodification.



Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Open letter to Mr. Pazienza

Dear Chez,

I have been noticing your descent from simple grumpiness to downright tongue-tied furiosity on the Bubble Genius show lately and wanted to express a parallel to maybe help or at least provide some small measure of comfort during this time of crisis. Yes, the republic is in peril. Yes, the spectacle of brain-damaged conservatives pulling off stunt after stunt is disheartening. And yes, there is plenty of reason to believe this is the final plunge. Perhaps someone calling himself "The Gloomy Historian" is not the wellspring of hope to reassure you or your readers that all is not lost, but hear me out because this is certainly not the first time our country and democracy has so brazenly embraced self-destruction. "Darkest before dawn" may be a tired cliché, but in the story to follow it turned out to be the truth and dawn held for a half century, until we forgot the lessons of that dark time.

A while back I sent you a message comparing Bob Cesca and yourself to the subjects of my MA thesis, Arthur Schlesinger jr. and Reinhold Niebuhr respectively. While I certainly do not consider myself an expert in the conventional sense on any of you, I believe there are enough similarities to make a convincing comparison. I know Bob loves history in the same way Schlesinger did and both combine that love with their advocacy of the pragmatic liberal position and pursuit of truth. You, Chez, on the other hand run from the religious faith that gave Niebuhr strength despite your regularly voicing the realist view Niebuhr developed and even quoting his Serenity Prayer. I am not suggesting you slide on down to the Triple Rock and catch Rev. Cleophus James for some churching up (YES! YES! JESUS H. TAP-DANCING CHRIST... I HAVE SEEN THE LIGHT!). In fact, your secularism provides evidence that religion is not required to find an ethical and moral code to live by.

It was the 1920s and conservative regression and reaction were ascendant and practically unchallenged. After beating back the war preparedness measures of the Wilson Administration and defeating America's entry into the League of Nations, Republicans unleashed and enabled corporate power beyond their wildest dreams. Reinhold Niebuhr was on the outside looking in. After a stint as a four minute man, selling a war he did not fully believe in and turning his back on his German ancestry, Niebuhr was deeply disillusioned by a trip to war-ravaged Europe that humanity really was doomed. The theologian abandoned many of his Christian convictions of pacifism in the belief that democracy and liberty were ideas worth fighting and sacrificing for, and suffered the disappointment of being alone on a weak branch. Niebuhr felt the Great War was the chance for America to live up to its ideals at home and finally exercise a responsible involvement among the community of nations. Instead, we abandoned the world and turned inward for profit and "normalcy." It was a horrible time to be a reformer and Niebuhr's writings of the time reflect his deep cynicism of opportunity lost and the incredible selfishness of American elites. I hope Chez, that you can see parallels. America has a tendency to let us down.

America of the 1920s was the jazz and automobile wonderland talked about in too many textbooks, but it was also a land of vast inequality in wealth and power. Labor was practically a spent force, workers scrambled on their own for scraps. Radio allowed news and entertainment to enter American homes, but it also gave a platform to venomous preachers of hate such as Charles Coughlin and Aimee Semple McPherson if that sounds familiar. Debt lost its traditional stigma as materialism and marketing, those twin banes of the American reform spirit, became a metaphorical plague of locusts. And the dark shades of speculation were rearing their voracious mouths to consume and destabilize the economy years before the crash in another familiar refrain. Henry Ford famously remarked that "history is bunk" but his outlook was not shared by the neo-confederate revisionists in the academy and the KKK. Lynching, intimidation, hate over the airwaves, and all against the backdrop of "entrepreneurial" con jobs and snake oil salesmen running roughshod over the quaint ideas of freedom and democracy chasing that almighty dollar.

The big difference today seems to be that the crash did not slap people out of this crassness, nor did Americans become "good neighbors" or find solidarity in shared privation against uncaring power. As a prominent writer, speaker, and thinker Niebuhr played a role in turning the tide after unbridled capitalism vomited all over the city on a hill. It is not easy to pinpoint when the change from "untamed cynic" to Christian Realist occurred in Niebuhr during America's great crisis. But after preaching the folly of 1920s vices that culminated in Moral Man and Immoral Society he was able to channel the revelations about human nature into an ideology of leftist reform that eschewed idealism for pragmatism. Niebuhr even had a nemesis on the left that you, Chez and Bob, could easily understand. The feud between Christian Realists and the followers of John Dewey's philosophy may be largely forgotten today, but it had much of the intensity (though not the venom) of rivalry between Greenwaldian emoprogs and the Daily Banter today.

It may be a long shot from our contemporary point of view, but Niebuhr's frustration and triumph (his ideas influenced everything from the New Deal to the Civil Rights movement) give evidence for hope that the confused and divided Children of Light will eventually get their act together and prevail over the moneyed interests and Children of Darkness that know no law beyond their own self-interest. Or we can give up and follow your prescriptions for dealing with the NRA, but you'd be on your own for that one. I have no stomach for force anymore.

Sincerely,
The Kraken

Monday, July 15, 2013

Let the hate flow through you




Is it even a surprise? An extremely divisive case begets an extremely divisive reaction to the verdict. A case that provides an horrific instance that not only is extreme polarization causing the United States to be ungovernable, but lawless as well. When anyone can pick up a gun, shoot anyone who "threatens" them, real or imagined, and get away with it; that is the state of nature imagined by Thomas Hobbes in Leviathan. A war of all against all.

The FB post where I took this meme from was decidedly anti-Martin, but this one is decidedly double-edged. Take this comment by "B. Oblamer" on a Politico story:
The jury did a fine responsible job and found for the defense based on the overwhelming evidence. A very fair trial. 
And this was a very, very tame one.

Later, a decidedly liberal philosophy professor I know posted the exact meme, somehow I do not think he would suffer the fools, now "instant lawyers" and experts on legal defense all over the interwebs, very gladly. Lawyers deal with the law, however poorly the laws are constructed or for whose benefit they are enforced. Even the above comment from "Oblamer" who probably put as much intellectual punch into that derp which his hamster brain could muster, manipulates anyone who reads it. "Responsible... fair... overwhelming evidence," this has got to be the racists' finest hour. Not only did they vicariously murder a proxy Barack Obama, but they got away with it. Cue the victory lap of gloating.

Just survey the comment section of any news story on the subject, this one from Daily Banter is representative. His/her name is Michale, this individual has deemed it their mission to respond to absolutely every comment even slightly critical of the jury's decision. If there is a single person fitting the "instant lawyer" description implied by the above meme, this is it. All I can say is in a million years I could not hope to have the kind of free time to waste that this individual has spent in the past few days locking down any chance of honest and rational debate. What kind of passionate hatred could drive this commitment? How much is he/she being paid by some authoritarian outfit to spend this much time here? Just a small sample.
cfdman  said:                                                                                                 
Let’s examine the undisputed evidence:

1. The man thought the teen looked suspicious.

2. The man called the police to report his suspicions about the teen.

3. The man was told by the police not to chase and pursue the teen.

4. The man decided to chase and pursue the teen anyway.

5 . The man was carrying a loaded gun.

6. The teen was not carrying a gun.

7. The teen was not carrying any weapon.

8. The teen was carrying candy.

9. The teen was not committing any crime.

10. The teen was not trespassing, as he was walking toward his father’s
condo....
17. But for the man chasing and pursuing the teen, there would have
been no physical confrontation.

18. But for the physical confrontation, there would have been no fight.

19. But for the fight, the man would not have shot the teen.

20. But for the shot, the teen would be alive.
Michale replied: "Your list of "undisputed evidence" is very much in dispute..
3. The man was told by the police not to chase and pursue the teen.
The man was ADVISED by a police operator not to follow the SUBJECT. A police operator has absolutely NO authority to tell on sight security personnel ANYTHING..
4. The man decided to chase and pursue the teen anyway.
Inaccurate. The man, at that point, turned around and started to return to his vehicle. In other words, he followed the advice of the police operator, even though he was under absolutely NO legal obligation to do so.
11. The man and the teen met in a physical confrontation.
Inaccurate. The teen initiated aggravated assault (with Hate Crime special circumstance) against the man while the man was returning to his vehicle.
12. The man and the teen fought, wrestled to the ground, and punches
were exchanged.

Inaccurate. No punches were exchanged. Martin was the only one throwing punches.
14. The man shot the teen while both were on the ground.
Inaccurate. The man shot the teen while the man was on the ground and the teen was on top of the man. 
17. But for the man chasing and pursuing the teen, there would have
been no physical confrontation.

Accurate as far as it goes. It is equally accurate to say that there would have been no confrontation if the teen hadn't doubled back and attacked the man. It's also equally accurate that there would not have been any confrontation if the teen hadn't been kicked out of school for drugs and violence.
20. But for the shot, the teen would be alive.
And if the teen hadn't attacked the man, the teen would ALSO be alive.."
He/she continued:

"One problem with your scenario.
Martin attacked Zimmerman.
That tiny little, but oohh so important detail completely decimates your argument.."

The comment thread goes on and on with this individual injecting these kinds of faux legal sounding shout-downs everywhere. I scanned through page after page of this crap. How many of these idiots are out there? They have just been waiting and waiting for the chance to frame their racism through a legal case like this. "No, I'm not a racist, I am supporting the 'justice' system." For authoritarians, this is a dream come true, wonderful cover to aggress against the enemy, the ability to openly and honestly express their prejudice couched in legalese, and prostrate themselves to authority when they like the result. So, in response I say: "Are there any circumstances under which you can support the verdict, actively, not just passively accepting the outcome, and not be a racist?" I ask because I honestly cannot think of any. and flipping the circumstances of the crime around... Would he/she be asserting the opposite as vehemently, or would he/she suddenly notice that GZ is not white enough?

And how stupid does all that gloating look in light of the fact that GZ was acquitted, not exonerated. There was enough reasonable doubt not to convict, this was not a vindication. Thank goodness for all the racists that tomorrow will bring a new outrage and everyone will move on (sarcasm font) and not notice how completely full of shit people like Michale are in their whacked out assertions.