Monday, June 20, 2016

The "Liberal" Class: The Dark Side of Meritocracy

I just finished Thomas Frank's Listen Liberal on audio and am now depressed. Dr. Frank, as always, lays out the way it is and after several books analyzing the ideological underpinnings of Republican voters and their leaders he has turned his keen eye on the Democrats. It is not a pretty sight. Frank's book is subtitled "what happened to the party of the people?" His answer is that the Democratic Party has been taken over by a variety of liberal that holds itself as the highest expression of that ideology. Frank has termed this gaggle of professionals "the liberal class" and leaders like Bill Clinton, Barack Obama, and Hillary Clinton are at the top. What distinguishes this faction within the party from others is their slavish devotion to meritocracy, which on it's face is a good thing, we need competence and expertise in government. But meritocracy values education above all else, which has led to disdain for all other pursuits, and therefore the "liberal class" has no interest in working people or their issues. This in turn has lead to the greatest explosion of inequality in America since the Civil War, or perhaps ever.

And that is a real problem, to put it mildly. This is basically what people are getting at when they complain that the two major parties in America are equally bad. This is also how the once proud "Party of the People" has simply become the "lesser of two evils". Usually, the word "spineless" was always at the forefront of criticism from the left, but cowardice is not the explanation Frank uses to describe how the Democratic elite abandoned it's traditional constituency of working people. Well, not abandoned completely, Frank points out in gloomy fashion that during the 2012 presidential campaign the issues of working class people were brought to the forefront to attack Mitt Romney but quickly faded away again.

No, the reason the Democratic Party abandoned working people and are all wrong about the overarching issue of the day, wealth and income inequality, is that professionals that make up the elite within that party don't care anymore. Education, namely the elite private university you went to and how well you did there, is the only thing that matters. Instead of the crude materialism of the right wing kleptocracy, we have an oligarchy of intellect and character. But neither one cares particularly about the needs of working people. Frank echoes Noam Chomsky a bit on this issue, though while Chomsky traces (or attempts to trace, he is not an historian after all) the meritocratic elite back to the founding of the republic, Frank located a specific moment in time when the Democratic Party killed the New Deal and sought the attentions of the highly educated.

The tumultuous political year 1968 has been brought up numerous times this election season, especially before Trump became the presumptive nominee and there was a very real possibility of a contested convention. Back then it was the Democrats who had a crazy (to put it mildly) convention in Chicago, and out of it came the McGovern commission that reformed the nomination process. These reforms ensured that delegates to the convention reflected the demographics of America but set off a series of changes locking organized labor and working people out of positions of influence, according to Frank. Who needs those uncultured racist, sexist, uneducated union types anyway? The new Democratic ideal was the highly educated professional liberal, the one that is inclusive of gender and ethnicity, all others need not apply.

When these elite professionals have gained class consciousness and deal only with each other it is not difficult to see how they would then condescend to their inferiors, which Frank goes over in excruciating detail. An article he wrote on billionaire liberalism over two years ago had stuck in my head and I was miraculously able to find it in the pit of despair that is Salon's archive. Here he describes the Mugwump by quoting and paraphrasing the great Richard Hofstadter. The Mugwump is as committed to cleaning up government as he is to disciplining the poor, fighting corruption and making the working classes behave, and he the Mugwump is in a privileged position of wealth and influence to make his will known. This is what people hate about "liberals", what Frank talked about with regards to Michael Bloomburg:
If that description hits uncomfortably close to home, well, good. We’ve returned to the Gilded Age, laissez-faire is common sense again, and Victorian levels of inequality are back. The single greatest issue of then is the single greatest issue of now, and once again people like Bloomberg—a modern-day Mugwump if ever there was one—have nothing useful to say about it, other than to remind us when it’s time to bow before the mighty. Oh, Bloomberg could be relentless in his mayoral days in his quest for sin taxes, for random police authority, for campaigns against sugary soda and trans fats. But put a “living wage” proposal on his desk, and he would denounce it as a Soviet-style interference in private affairs.
Gone are the campaigns to organize workers on the shop floor, in are the campaigns against smoking. Gone are the push for real laws to redress inequality, in are the glorious exhortations to free trade. Yes, the elite liberal wants those disgusting people at Wal-Mart to shape up. They naturally gravitate towards that bastion of professional greatness (ho ho) in high finance.

For the most part, Frank does not even go into how this problem of a Democratic elite on the wrong side of so many issues about inequality can be solved in Listen, Liberal. But this article at least lights the way. We, the working people of America, have faced this professional class betrayal before during the long Gilded Age before the New Deal. All we need to do is look at how working people got together before and fought for their rights and their piece of the American Dream. After all, this "liberal" class is but one faction within the party, there must be a way to peel them away from identifying with all the other factions that are killing the country and the economy. We have to go back to square one and learn what it takes to persuade our own leaders. If Bernie Sanders' campaign anything it was this.

Friday, June 17, 2016

Will they show up?

Lovely, more jargon to learn. This one might be worth it though. SINO: supporter in name only is definitely an issue that explains the weakness of political parties and other organizations in the age of social media. Chuck McCutcheon, writing at the Christian Science Monitor, used the term in describing big wheel officials that can make a difference in trumps campaign. I am actually interested in how the loose affiliation among regular voters will affect the alt right or hard right as a movement. 


This was a problem for anti-war and civil rights activists in the sixties too, there were a few committed organizers and a lot of people who would show up for events and then disappear. But is it possible that the gaggle on Facebook and Twitter that talks a good fight will fail to show up when it counts?

Manifesto For the Feeble-minded

Yes, who are these ignorant bigots that support the vulgar talking yam? And why shouldn't we be surprised that their identity can fit in a meme? Who actually made this thing? I don't want to say where I found this but let's say it is not your typical rally goer. I don't know if that makes him a simpleton but is Quisling out really the best way to protect your masculinity and guns? When the Trumptergreifung  occurs do you really think "I'm on your side" is going to protect you from the Klan members or keep you out of a concentration camp? The lack of spelling errors or glaring grammatical mistakes makes me think this was a professional job but despite many different queries to the Google I could not trace this meme's progression.

Makes one think that there is some order to the flag encrusted bullet points if it was actually designed and not slap-assed together. Let's see: "hate", "repealed", "sick of", "fed-up with", "tired of", and a lot of "wants"; this is the whiniest document I've seen in some time. First off, you fascist pricks don't "hate liberal ideology" you hate liberals, your fellow Americans, and you want them disappeared. You couldn't define liberalism if you wanted to, beyond what Fox News and Rush Limbaugh have programmed you to recite on command, which bears no resemblance to real world liberalism. No, you hate liberals, which you define as anyone who disagrees with you. I'm surprised that hating Black Lives Matter didn't make this list, or would that have been too obvious?

Second, Obamacare repeal. Why? So you can go back to being at the mercy of insurance companies? The Affordable Care Act was based on a Republican proposal from the Heritage Foundation. Which part do you want back so badly, the one where your kids are kicked off at 18 or where the insurance company drops you or refuses to cover you because you might get sick? Or are you mad because poor people got some help paying their premiums? Just a good ole' punch down. But then you want "our vets taken care of", yes I do too, but who created all those vets who need care and then turned around and cut their benefits and funding VA hospitals? Yes that was George W. Bush, but he never existed in 'wingerdom so never mind that.

Hillary for prison? Yeah, I've seen that T-Shirt. Someone sure is raking in the dough from that one. Couldn't impeach President Obama for anything so it's time to up the ante some more. Please, by all means, hold your breath and stomp up and down, I'm sure eventually you can wish her to jail. From the looks of the Trump U case I'd say the vulgar talking yam ending up in prison is the more likely scenario. Corruption? Sure, I'm with you there but it takes a special kind of stupid to believe sending one of the most corrupt businessmen in America to the White House will do anything but ramp up corruption to Jupiter and back. Same with bringing jobs back, I'd love that too but again, Trump has outsourced so much of his own schemes is he really the one you trust to "renegotiate" trade deals?

Self-funded, now there is the ultimate exercise in self-delusion. First of all Trump loaned money to his campaign and expects to make it back with interest from all of you gullible idiots. Second, the first thing he did after securing the presumptive nomination was to declare that he was going to raise a billion dollars from all those special interests. The same ultra-wealthy owners of corporations that outsource jobs and hire illegal immigrants to push down your wages and standard of living. But hang on to that dream kiddies.


Wednesday, June 8, 2016

Time to Win it for the American People

It has been a long time coming but now Hillary Clinton is actually, finally the Democratic nominee for president. When I first heard the boogieman charge that she was going to run for president from talk radio blowhards in 2000 I wasn't scared. All of the stupid objections to having a woman as president, of which I won't recount, are just that, stupid. Is she going to be a perfect, wonderful embodiment of liberalism and perfectly represent the party of the people? No, probably not but she is eminently qualified to hold the office and be the Chief Executive of the country. I will vote for her and not hold my nose, and not only because the alternative is so unworthy and unqualified but because we deserve a decent and competent president.

Two coincidences cross in my opinion on the matter. The first concerns Bernie Sanders and the second concerns the Democratic Party. In the book review I just completed a major theme was the corrupting capacity of power and Bernie may have rode this wave a little too long. Chez Pazienza may be a little harsh in his characterization of Sanders:
Maybe Bernie Sanders really is a bitter, entitled crank, who at some point stopped running an eminently moral campaign dedicated to the issues and started simply being drunk on the thrill of being every Millennial's imaginary best friend.
Daniel Allen Butler described the rise of the Mahdi in late nineteenth century as beginning as a noble campaign to cleanse Islam of corruption and throw off foreign rule but ending as corrupt and power mad as the worst abuses he started out criticizing. Having a cause you believe in so passionately can spill over into excess, sometimes you have to step back and ask what you really want and what you really are doing. By past metrics of real left liberal candidates running for the Democratic nomination Bernie did incredibly well, pushing the conversation in the correct direction if we are ever going to straighten out the horrific inequality, insecurity, and poverty the majority of Americans struggle with every day. But through whatever function, the Sanders campaign pushed past that real game change and into quixotic territory.

Which brings me to the second coincidence. I just finished Thomas Frank's Listen Liberal book and after the initial bout of extreme despair have come to see that the exact same problem of succumbing to excess applies to the Democratic Party as well. I was skeptical of Frank's thesis at first, and really felt that now was not the time for a burning magnifying glass to blister and fragment the one adult party left in US politics but yeah, it's true that the professional ethos has taken over official liberalism and left the majority of us behind. So while ultimately unsuccessful in having a millennial course correction of the national Democratic Party, Bernie Sanders did give that insular professional class enough of a shock to maybe loosen them up a bit. It remains to be seen of course, and ultimately we liberals with an eye towards the New Deal ideas have no choice but to stick with the rogue's gallery of professionals now running things. The alternative of enthroning the mob and vulgar talking yam combined with the tea party fanatics ready to burn the whole country down at a moment's notice is not something to contemplate lightly.

So congratulations Secretary Clinton, soon you will be president. Can you do more than fend off the authoritarian reactionaries and give the rest of us a reason to believe in you? I, for one, really hope so. I want President Clinton to be the decent and competent Chief Executive we need. But I also want her to prove Thomas Frank wrong about the calcification of professional liberalism and begin to reclaim the Democrats as the party of the people.  

Book Review: The First Jihad



Recently the movie Khartoum, starring everyone's favorite NRA figurehead Charlton Heston, was on TV. I was suddenly filled with the desire to know more about this event in history and looked it up on the public library's website. The first, and I believe most recent, entry was this book by Daniel Allen Butler so I put it on hold. Mrs. Kraken laughed a little when I told her I wanted something to read that would be a little more light-hearted and said that only someone as weird as me would think that this was light reading. But nevertheless, I finished it in less than three days and found it overall an accessible narrative of a real life adventure. The First Jihad is a light, fast read; and as far as I could tell is a valid account of the tale with accurate descriptions of actors and events. That said, this book was crying out for an editor or at least a better one.

The dust jacket described the author's education at fancy sounding universities, his eight years in the Army with six of those in the intelligence division, and his hobbies. The book seemed to have a hard time finding a classification, was it history, military or political science, commentary on militant Islam past and present? First and foremost this book was not scholarly, meaning it is basically useless for academics, there were no footnotes or endnotes but the bibliography did contain a variety of sources including primary ones so that is a positive. Butler seemed to want to use the story of the Mahdi and Islamic uprising in the Sudan to inform the present day war on terror, but couldn't commit fully to the task. Nor did he bring any new interpretations of existing scholarship on the Mahdi or Gordon.

Second, editorship. Good grief I don't think I have ever read a book that contained so many typos and grammatical errors. Of course, compared to a blog post or one of those fly by night websites that take and publish mostly freelance political commentary articles The First Jihad was practically spotless, but actually printing a book on paper with a hardcover and dust jacket that can't be edited once it leaves the press should be held to a higher standard. It was jarring and distracting to read "there" when it should be "their" or a simple word is misspelled. And it breaks up your focus and rhythm of reading when a sentence is badly constructed and you have to back up to try and make sense of it. Maybe it is just a little thing, but the publisher should have spent a little money to hire more or better editors to make sure there aren't glaring mistakes.

Third, Butler made some real historical errors in his prose. I cannot speak to the events in and around Khartoum in 1884 as that was the subject I was trying to learn more about. But in surveying the history of Islam and branching into the Crusades Butler wrote that Sultan Mehmet renamed Constantinople Istanbul after capturing that last remnant of the Eastern Roman Empire in 1453 when the city did not change names until after the First World War nearly five centuries later. There were other examples but that one stuck out to me. And the mistakes were not confined to Medieval history, in a section referring to the war on terror and George W. Bush's infamous phrase about "smoking the terrorists out of their holes" Butler then used the British idea of "winkling the other fellow out of his hole" as though the two ideas were equivalent. They are not, "winkling" is trying to get an enemy to surrender while "smoking" is to either kill the enemy in their hole or flush him out into the open where he can be killed.

Even with these problems though the book was enjoyable. I'm probably just jealous that I did not try to write a book like it. Or angry that while we both served in the Army, Butler seems to have not internalized the attention to detail that I did. Little things to be sure, but those are some sloppy errors that stood out to me. So, with those in mind hopefully you can enjoy the book a little more should you ever go through the same steps I did of seeing Khartoum on TV and wanting to get a more detailed picture of the actual history. Happy Reading!

Tuesday, June 7, 2016

Family Planning Doublethink


I'm still amazed at how often the sort of meme above still appears now that the "conservative" movement has gone full racist in their breathless approval of Donald Trump. We will dispense with providing examples of racism from Trump and his supporters, i.e. the Republican base, and move on to concept of holding two contradictory ideas in your head at once and accepting both as true. I found this one at the bottom of a reply thread posted by an epic troll calling himself "Dindu Nuffins". Sanger never said this, Snopes dot com debunked an even more spurious claim that she included Latins, Slavs, and Hebrew immigrants. I have been writing about Eugenics for three years now (example here), Margaret Sanger and the family planning movement in America has not been the focus of my research but it takes a few clicks to find that this is a fabrication, misattribution, or a lie; take your pick. The doublethink on the part of Trumpeters is holding the idea that black people are bad and that somehow a progressive movement headed by Sanger sought to exterminate black people which was also bad. That Planned Parenthood clinics are somewhat more common in poor neighborhoods that serve minority populations also means the existence of a systematic campaign to control or eliminate reproduction by those minorities through voluntary contraception and abortion services. Even that is not true, and the fact that 'winger's heads don't explode when they suppress the thought of "wait a minute, I'd actually really like it if welfare queens couldn't have kids" demonstrates a mastery of holding two contradictory ideas at once and using one's true desire to smear your opponent.

Just as a refresher I found this concise definition of doublethink as introduced in George Orwell's 1984.
In 1984, the Party used doublethink as part of its large-scale campaign of propaganda and psychological manipulation of its leadership and the public. Doublethink is the ability to hold two completely contradictory beliefs at the same time and to believe they are both true. Early in the book, doublethink refers to the ability to control your memories, to choose to forget something, as well as to forget about the forgetting process. Later on in the novel, as the Party implements its mind-control techniques, people ultimately lose the ability to form independent thoughts. Eventually, it becomes possible for the Party to convince the public of anything, even if it's the exact opposite of what the public already knows to be true.
Orwell defines doublethink as, ''To know and to not know, to be conscious of complete truthfulness while telling carefully constructed lies, to hold simultaneously two opinions which cancelled out, knowing them to be contradictory and believing in both of them, to use logic against logic, to repudiate morality while laying claim to it, to believe that democracy is impossible and that the Party was the guardian of democracy. To forget, whatever it was necessary to forget, then to draw it back into memory again at the moment when it was needed, and then promptly to forget it again, and above all, to apply the same process to the process itself.''
Is it just conscious trolling to have right wingers say that all African-Americans are criminal, lazy, awful parents in one breath and then clutch their pearls over the insidious plot by liberals and Planned Parenthood to wipe African-Americans out? Or can they really put everything they said about "thugs" and "paid protesters" away, forgetting that they forgot? Robert Altemeyer described the ability of right wing authoritarian followers to compartmentalize their thoughts so that no matter how contradictory the ideas were they will never touch and spark cognitive dissonance in the individual. Or is it actually simpler than that? Is it just that when 'wingers are presented with an opportunity to "get" liberals or Democrats, they take it and don't really care what the contradiction is? In an online discussion with liberals, trolls put aside their racism to take a swing with something as absurd as the meme above just because they hate liberals more. It would be nice if they were honest with their bigotry, but this is where we are.

If you have the guts, I suggest checking out one of the new white supremacist sites to see the dichotomy. Those guys are for real, they really hate minorities and mean it. Most trolls I have encountered seem to see racism as a hobby, pointing out bad behavior by African-Americans or other minorities is just another tool to attack Democrats and liberals such as the oft-repeated line about Democrats being in charge of big cities where riots occur and crime is rampant. Yeah, that Rahm Emanuel is such a Progressive. Or when they whip out the "straying off the plantation" line. But that one is usually followed up by an exhortation to get off welfare, get a job, marry your baby momma, etc. So the partisan Republican racism is usually just way to get under the skin of liberals no matter what color it is.

Maybe it is a bizarre form of outreach to African-American Democrats by Republicans. After all, the two main sources of the myth of genocidal Margaret Sanger has come from Black Republicans. Ben Carson and Herman Cain tried using the fantasy of Planned Parenthood being out to get them in their respective presidential runs. I think the line got more rebuttals than support though; Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post, Bob Cesca on the Daily Banter, and Martha Raddatz of ABC all debunked the tenuous grasp of reality that Messrs Cain and Carson had on what Planned Parenthood does or even what Eugenics is. I wrote about it at the time of Carson's mumblings too. But why would 'winger trolls care about facts, empirical history, or even logic? Basically what 'winger trolls who paint Sanger and Planned Parenthood as evil and by extension any Democrat who supports PP are saying is "come over to our side black brothers and sisters, we only want to put you back in your proper place in society, the Democrats secretly want to exterminate you." The conspiracy theorists like Alex Jones may buy every rumor about evil Progressives and their social engineering and secret breeding programs, but it appears that African-American voters are not as gullible.

It is a strange though epic projection for 'wingers to claim that their liberal enemies are the ones who want to exterminate African-Americans. And it seems to be only the desire to not sink to that level that liberals defending PP and birth control don't point that out. Whether it is true doublethink, mere compartmentalization, or the fact that these are sociopathic liars who just don't give a damn that what they spew makes no sense makes very little difference. The past is still with us, it isn't even past. As Hillary Clinton slowly and inexorably moves toward the White House, this kind of woman-hating and racist bullshit is going to get worse and worse.

Friday, May 27, 2016

The Rand Rebellion



I picked up this book some time ago when Rick Perlstein was attempting to identify the Trump supporters' ideology and what the short-fingered vulgarian himself believes. This was before the violence at Trump rallies became commonplace, before the "lion guard" brownshirts spontaneously assembled, and before the ur-fascism of this gaggle of nutballs was completely fleshed out. Perlstein argued that what Trump represented was a herrenvolk democratic tradition of white people getting preference and privilege, while nonwhites get the shaft. This was a new concept for me so after some searching I found George M. Fredrickson's comparative study in American (South) and South African history that promised to demonstrate historical aspects of the phenomenon.

It has been very instructive, but not exactly what the incoherent mass of idiots breathlessly parrot from their dear leader about making America great again. However I found this incident that I thought would be worth passing on. (pp. 232-4)

A major confrontation between white workers and the mining industry became inevitable when the immediate post-war period fround the mines in an economic crisis because of a combination of rising costs and declining gold prices. An effort by the Chamber of Mines to abrogate the "status quo agreement" led to the extraordinary series of events that became known as the Rand Rebellion. In December 1921, the Chamber proposed to limit the color bar to skilled work strictly defined and to displace about 2,000 semi-skilled whites by lower-paid blacks. Despite the refusal of the unions to agree, the industry announced plans to go ahead with this reorganization of the labor force beginning on February 1, 1922. In an effort to head off this action the mine unions were already out in protest against wage reductions. The strike escalated into an insurrection, partly because Afrikaner unionists (who by now constituted the great majority of the white miners) organized themselves into para-military "commandos." In the words of Fredrick A. Johnstone, "the traditional fighting formation of the Afrikaner farmers" was adapted "to a new setting, that of urban, industrial class conflict." The commandos were used to enforce the strike, drive away scabs, and eventually to resist the government troops called out by Prime MInister Jan Smuts. After the strikers had taken full control of the Rand, called for a general strike of white workers to support them in their demands, and begun to launch sporadic attacks on African miners, the government declared martial law on March 10 and moved in 7,000 troops, backed by bombing planes, tanks, and all the paraphernalia of modern warfare. Armed conflict raged for four days, during which between 150 and 220 people were killed and 500-600 wounded. The strike was finally crushed and its leaders arrested; eighteen were condemned to death anf four actually executed. The Chamber of MInes then proceeded with its reorganization of the work force by lowering wages and laying off a substantial number of whites. In 1923, a court decision declared the legally enforced color bar ultra vires, or contrary to common law, thus providing the industry with a free hand to make further retrenchments in white labor.
The white workers and other defenders of a rigid industrial color bar had lost a battle but not the war itself. In the parliamentary election of 1924, a coalition of Afrikaner Nationalists and the South African Labour Party drove Smuts's South African Party from office by capitalizing on the backlash inspired by the government's fierce repression of the Rand Rebellion and its general record of insensitivity to white working class demands for iron clad protection against African competition. The resulting "Pact Government" under Nationalist Prime Minister J. B. M. Hertzog re-enacted the mining color bar in a more explicit and definitive way in 1926. Addressing the long-festering "poor white problem" more directly, it also inaugurated a set of policies that included displacing black workers with higher-paid whites on government-owned railroads, subsidizing municipalities to permit hiring of white laborers at "civilized" wages, and utilizing minimum-wage determinations and tariff adjustments to force employers in the growing manufacturing sector to increase the proportion of whites in their work force. The industrial color bar and the "civilized labor policy" completed the basic pattern of government-supported discrimination in the South African economy. Whites were to be guaranteed jobs, artificially high wages, and exclusive access to skilled work--all at the expense of African aspirations. The foundations of industrial apartheid were laid.
To put this conflict and its resolution in proper perspective, it is essential to recognize that neither side wanted a free-labor market; hence it was not a contest between equal opportunity and legalized discrimination. The mine-owners and other capitalistic interests were responsible for the the primary act of discrimination when they combined forces and called on government support to hold down African wages and bargaining power. They thereby set the stage for a virtually unavoidable conflict between a disfranchised, semi-servile, and ultra-cheap class of workers and another segment of the labor force that had the capacity to organize and exert political influence. As in the case of the Chinese-exclusion movement in the United States, white labor had the one crucial advantage in this struggle. Although their position was not inherently more discriminatory than that of employers who took advantage of the vulnerability of nonwhites to hire them on terms that "free workingmen" would never accept, the struggle inexorably took a form that allowed spokesmen for white labor to identify their cause as that of white supremacy and thus tap the deep wells of prejudice existing in the larger white or European population. If the labor movement in California could appeal to middle-class xenophobia, spokesmen for white workers in South Africa could draw upon the rural Afrikaner's traditional conviction that the white man's privileges and security must be absolutely guaranteed. hence the immediate material interests of organized labor coincided with traditional racial prejudices in a much more direct and obvious way than those of the employers.
South African industrialists found they could live with the legal color bar--which was eventually extended from mining to other forms of industry--because it turned out to be compatible with their primary concern for maintaining a cheap supply of ultra-exploitable African indentured workers. The surplus of unskilled whites in the 1920s and 30s was only temporary (ending completely with World War II and the subsequent growth of the South African economy) and was largely channeled into state-owned enterprises like the railroads or the iron and steel industry (ISCOR), which could pay "civilized wages" because they did not have to compete directly with private capital and maintain a high rate of profit. Hence there were never enough whites available to displace Africans in low-skilled jobs within private industry. Furthermore, the bar to African advancement into skilled jobs helped rationalize the migratory labor system and denial of African bargaining rights. If blacks had no chance of advancement into the skilled occupations, not much was really lost by shuttling them back and forth in a way that limited their ability to acquire advanced industrial training. The transformation of the entire white working class into a "labor aristocracy" that shared with businessmen and farmers an interest in holding down and exploiting Africans diminished the possibility of class conflict among whites and may have served the interests of South African capitalism better than either a genuinely free labor market--which might have enabled workers to organize across racial lines--or a split, competitive situation that could breed the kind of dangerous and divisive conflict that had erupted on the rand in 1922.