Showing posts with label Rick Perlstein. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rick Perlstein. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 28, 2019

Normalcy isn't a real word and it definitely won't work

This morning I came across a very interesting conversation within the Democratic family. As Driftglass and Bluegal always like to say, the debates occurring now in Primary season are a family discussion. This is how it always goes during Primary season, there are a thousand or more points of view within the big tent of the Democratic Party and it takes a while to settle things down to just a few. The problem is when these conversations become arguments and the partisans within each group get entrenched and bitter. While the Republicans are almost entirely authoritarian at this point, RWAFs in the base and social dominators in leadership and wannabe leadership, the Democrats are not without authoritarians of the left-wing variety. Whereas right wing authoritarian followers prize conformity and obedience to power along with aggression against any out-groups, left wing authoritarians prize perpetual rebellion and individualism. Bernie bros and Naderites are the classic cases and they did plenty of damage with their purity tests and privilege of saying "let the Republican win, that will show 'em." Obviously it is a scale, there aren't hard and fast delinations marking each group. But each family fight has the potential of setting off LWAs and forming schisms within the party that can ruin elections.

So I have to try and temper any remarks because I don't want to fan a spark into a schism or empower LWAs at all. First and foremost, as I have mentioned before, I don't take positions in Primaries because the worst Democrat is always better than the best Republican. We have a pretty good group of competent, experienced candidates with good ideas that will all represent the Party and the non-insane majority of this country well. Joe Biden is the candidate at the heart of this conversation. It starts with Brother Charlie Pierce's column from August 26, arguing that Biden is the "return to normalcy" candidate with great similarity to Warren G. Harding. Rick Perlstein upped the ante by stating:
Ah, our very own James Buchanan: the rocky-steady candidate of experience, promising to bring back all that yummy, yummy normalcy. I'm sure it will all work out swell, just like 1856-60.
Now, both Harding and Buchanan are consistently ranked among the worst presidents this country has had in our history by professional historians. Personally I rank James K. Polk higher in the awfulness chart for waging an aggressive war of conquest against Mexico based on lies that empowered southern slave owners into forcing their demands for more slavery and more oppression onto the rest of the country. Maybe because the parallels with Dubya and Cheney's contempt for the rule of law and empowering the worst people in the country to shit all over democracy are just too strong. In my reading of history, Polk doused the country in gasoline with his splendid little war and gave boxes of matches to authoritarian slave owners. Sure, there was a short interregnum with Whig presidents (Zachary Taylor, hero of the war with Mexico then Fillmore) where the country could have gone in another direction but the same kind of normalcy set in once Franklin Pierce (no relation to Charlie, that I know of) took office. Pierce was a doughface, actually the poster child for doughfaces, who wasn't going to do anything about slavery because he saw the abolitionists as the problem.

There is no going back. WWI changed the country in many, many ways. Though Harding and his successors tried to go back to the federal government doing nothing and retreat from internationalism, the world and much of America did not really cooperate. Similarly, Buchanan just tried to ignore the simmering divisions and violent trends with a lighter touch on the doughface identity. But even an experienced, long-serving politician like Buchanan could not sweep things away by inaction, simply hoping that not making waves could patch things up so we could go back to arguing over tariffs and internal improvements instead of slavery and expansion.

So, no amount of hoping a Joe Biden could patch things up after doughfacedonny goes away will suffice. There is simply no going back. And according to FiveThirtyEight Biden's lead is shrinking, so it's possible that the issue of having to hash out who is right in their comparison won't persist into Primary season. I like and respect both Charlie and Rick, and I'm on board with their basic premise that trying to campaign on the return to normalcy will probably be a disaster. No schism here, if Biden gets the nomination I will obviously vote for him but then immediately go back to organizing and working to defeat authoritarianism. Even if that means watching Diamond Joe lead with his face into republican baseball bats.

Thursday, May 19, 2016

American Chivalry


It has been a long time since I reviewed a film on this blog. And this is kind of a shame because I love movies, and so did one of the principle intellectuals I studied for my MA thesis. Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. loved the cinema the way George Will loves baseball, Reinhold Niebuhr loved God, and the way Driftglass loves to tell every member of the beltway's pundit class that they are full of it. Schlesinger felt that cinema was the American art form, more than jazz or rock and roll, and though he did not shoehorn a film reference into his writing very often, when he did it was to make a strong point. So in that vein I will try to make the point strongly that historical movies are fun and usually entertaining, but no substitute for real knowledge. What movies can do, however, is inspire our better angels to be better than we are. It is important that we aspire to an ideal.

Though I cannot hold a candle to the ways Rick Perlstein works movie references into his writing and successfully frames serious historical study with the tool of the theater. The way he seamlessly does here to immerse the reader who may otherwise be have no reference point for the crime wave of New York City during Trump's formative years with clips to Death Wish, Taxi Driver, and Serpico. I believe this to be one of the proper uses of film for historical purposes, to give atmosphere or big picture perspective to the past in a comparatively easy medium but not for real detail. Another way is to tell timeless tales of human struggle as allegories or even idealized notions of what our national character is. An example is our concept of chivalry. Chivalry in the Middle Ages was an ideology certainly, one that was almost universally impossible to live up to, but an idealized standard to strive for. Google defines the word as "the combination of qualities expected of an ideal knight, especially courage, honor, courtesy, justice, and a readiness to help the weak." 

So what is the American interpretation of Chivalry? My wife and I recently watched Trumbo and Bridge of Spies, and I believe we can extract from these two films some combination of qualities expected of an ideal American. At least from a liberal point of view. While I do not always buy into the notion of Hollywood being peopled exclusively with bleeding hearts, see the above films that Perlstein cited to support his idea of avenging angel conservatism, the unthinking, reflexive brand of conservatism that I often deride as authoritarianism is rightfully cast as the bad guy in Trumbo. While in Bridge of Spies the Cold War is a character in itself, with characters and institutions reacting to the boogieman. This film also, to its credit, really helps recast the confrontation between East and West as the nuanced exercise in statecraft that it was.

Americans have an ideal vision of our republic as the home of freedom, where we have the right to say and believe what we choose. We have often fallen from that ideal state of being. Only a few short years after the passage of the Bill of Rights, the government was passing laws abridging the freedom of expression and most aspects of the first amendment in the Alien and Sedition Acts. Antebellum Southern politicians passed all sorts of laws restricting the postage of anti-slavery pamphlets through the mail. Abraham Lincoln suspended habeas corpus and violated many civil liberties during the Civil War. And A. Mitchell Palmer rounded up and either jailed or deported thousands of aliens after World War I in the first Red Scare. These are just a few examples of what Schlesinger called "political delirium tremons" where the proverbial "we" acted rashly and felt bad about it afterwards. Well maybe not in the case of southern slave owners.

These are official violations of the first amendment, "congress shall pass no law", but how many popular movements in American history have also violated our ideals of freedom? We had all sorts of anti-Catholic, anti-masonry, know-nothing groups in our past who discriminated, intimidated, and blacklisted anyone who didn't fit their idea of Americanism. To say nothing of the dirty and often violent tactics of corporations against their own workers. 

In Trumbo, there was a combination of official and popular repression at work. Helen Mirran's witch-hunting columnist character, Hedda Hopper, was certainly vile and much of her vitriol seemed personal, as though she were simply jealous of Trumbo's success and talent. And then J. Parnell Thomas the poster child for the separation of powers. You can just pick an adjective for why people dislike politicians and he fits the bill. Grandstanding, pandering, self-righteous, vindictive, and corrupt Thomas really was the perfect warm up act for both Joseph McCarthy and Richard Nixon. Whether apocryphal or not, Trumbo's snappy comeback upon seeing Thomas in prison was so perfect, "the difference between you and me is that you actually committed a crime."

I know that I am usually the first to get bent out of shape over the movies taking liberties when recounting an historical episode, but as chivalric tales of what America is meant to be I am willing to suspend my disbelief as it were. Now it will take a lot more research than that necessary for a movie review to examine the historical Trumbo's ideology, but I suspect the filmmakers softened his communism to make it more palatable for audiences and highlight both the injustice and Trumbo's triumph. The way he explains what he believes to his daughter sounds just like a run of the mill New Deal liberal. Louis C. K.'s character Arlen was a lot more believable as the humorless true believer constantly trying to insert digressions about the plight of workers into scripts that were so out of place even pig-headed Republicans could spot it. I'm not sure who's interest that angle of the story served. Perhaps just a reminder that there were communists who were serious, but just as Arlen was a pitiable and pathetic character, so were the actual American communists. In her account of the Red Scare titled Scoundrel Time, Lillian Hellman talked about how silly the communists she knew were and how they were about as dangerous to American liberty and democracy as the Greens are today. 

The point of it all was that McCarthyism was largely a partisan, grandstanding affair by Republicans, a half-assed attempt to smear Democrats and anyone on the left. The FBI, though fallible and not above political chicanery, was perfectly competent to weed out any actual Soviet agents and dangerous domestic communists. As Bridge of Spies showed. Though this film never made it plain what the spy Rudolf Abel was up to or if he was actually dangerous he was clearly working for the Soviets and was rightfully arrested. Now, nations have been spying on each other since the dawn of time. That is not really the issue of American chivalry addressed in the film, but how we behave in the great game of espionage. So, the next time your Trump supporting uncle goes off about the Muslims or whatever, ask him about this film. Do you want to behave like any other barbaric nation? Do you identify with the anonymous asshole drive by shooters trying to intimidate Tom Hanks? Or would you rather be the true American who believes in our laws and our rights, even when extended to people you don't like? That is basically what it comes down to.

All we are is what we want to be. Perhaps these two films can help some of us remember that fact. We want to be the best that we can be. We believe in justice and democracy. We believe in law. We believe in protecting the individual and we rejoice in our pluralism and tolerance for difference. That is our chivalry. That is our ideal. It's about time we start living up to it.

Thursday, August 13, 2015

Vietnam, Rick Perlstein, and Ur-Fascism

Searching for truth is a full-time job. A quest that this feeble blog will never complete. The chances of convincing an individual that they are being lied to, manipulated, or played for a fool is approaching statistical insignificance. Nonetheless, many people still commit themselves to learning and trying to pass on their knowledge and wisdom to the larger world. In a classroom this activity is usually met with blank stares and indifference, but in our hyper-polarized political climate it can be downright dangerous.

I have mentioned before that I am a former Army Tanker and a member of a tanker group on Facebook. I am also one of the very few anti-fascists in a sea of wannabe brown shirts. What started as an innocent way to keep in touch with my former brothers in arms has become embarrassing. The only reason I have not unfollowed the group is that it is enlightening to observe right wing memes and comments from some members. In between posting generally nasty memes about liberals or women or Democrats, scantily-clad women or downright terms of service violating nudie pics, or boasting about their guns, or taking pot shots at other branches of the military, there are people posting some outrage or another along with as much personal contact information as they can come up with about the perpetrators  and urging others to "go get 'em." Outrages like standing on the American flag, saying something negative about veterans or guns, generally anyone exercising the freedom of expression that all of these guys claim to defend but when it comes right down to it are hypocrites. So far none of these angry vets have actually attacked any of the targets but every mass shooting that occurs in America further de-stigmatizes the idea of political violence. I feel it is important to try and draw the authoritarian aggression sometimes on display into the open because it is harder to build up the resolve to do something one might regret outside the epistemic self-reinforcing system of closed Facebook groups. The potential for violence is what concerns me. Political or religious violence is the most dangerous road a society can travel.

I don't know anyone who has stood on the flag as an act of protest and find the phenomenon counter-productive, not worthy of comment. Nor do I get ruffled by other idiots flapping their gums about  veterans being dishonorable, or impersonating a soldier. And I could care less about porn put up by anyone. But when the threats start rolling in about someone I do kind of know and respect, it is time to speak up. Rick Perlstein is a fellow historian who has written some great books about the era I study and I have learned a lot from his work. His latest book is The Invisible Bridge: The Fall of Nixon and the Rise of Reagan and should be considered required reading for everyone interested in contemporary politics and why the reactionary right is as off the spectrum as it is today. But books are for people whose attention spans exceed those of fruit flies.

However, an article Perlstein wrote for the Washington Spectator that attempted to untangle one of the great con jobs of American propaganda in the service of authoritarianism, got the attention of 'wingers all over the place. This is part of a very important and as yet unfolding story of the American "stab in the back" surrounding the Vietnam War. You know the one "if only the damn 'libs had let us nuke Vietnam" and so on. Perlstein's essay is an abridged version of a chapter in his book mentioned above, "a bizarre psychic reversal" as he puts it about the POW-MIA flag and how it has been used to buttress America's victim status and cruelty by the North Vietnamese. And the propaganda symbol value this sympathy provides to American authoritarians. To the right wing authoritarian follower, it is a symbol of solidarity with phantoms that he will never admit do not exist. To the social dominator seeking to lead them, the flag is a cudgel to smear and demonize anyone who does not go along with the mythology. He originally tied this flag to the racist history of the Confederate flag and that is where the trouble started. 

Karoli already wrote up the fauxtrage and pearl clutching on display from Fox and Friends and the reactions from 'wingers. I just wanted to add how violently the so-called defenders of freedom reacted to Perlstein on a personal level. In case anyone actually believes that our brave men and women in uniform "will not obey unconstitutional orders, such as orders to disarm the American people, to conduct warrantless searches, or to detain Americans as “enemy combatants” in violation of their ancient right to jury trial" if ordered to by our tyrannical government. 

From the M1 tankers group [closed] on Facebook:

This is the civilian shit bag that wrote the POW/MIA story. Feel free to contact him and let him know how u feel. .
[Picture of Rick Perlstein's Facebook page]



Angry, well-armed, self-righteous, and ready to attack anyone who disagrees with them. This is not what I was taught in the military, apparently things have changed. Having to issue a lengthy apology for presenting a not patriotically correct historical theory based on actual empirical research is something I doubt Rick Perlstein was taught in graduate school either. Having to then make himself scarce on social media due to threats was probably not something he contemplated when he submitted the article. 

Update:

The author of the post in question found my response. As you can guess it was not well-received. After looking at Tim's page briefly I take back what I implied, he is not a fascist, just a vindictive special snowflake. I do not know why Rick Perlstein's article got him so angry. As you can see from the discussion he wasn't the only one, but there is no criticism of why the flag isn't what Perlstein argues it is, a demagogic propaganda symbol designed to cut off and prevent debate, which is exactly what happens in these exchanges. Juvenile character attacks and random, arbitrary name-calling as proxy for argument. As though simply mentioning keywords should trigger a Pavlovian response of aggression. I wonder if the information was presented in a less-antagonistic manner, would this untold story of the POW-MIA flag get a less rigid, knee-jerk, and aggressive response? I took this post down for a few days to edit it, because it was kind of unfair and was written in haste. After initially publishing I did a google search of responses to the original article for comparison, and whoa my findings make the comments I recorded here look civil by comparison. I am not going to link to anything ranting about "hate-filled kike demons" or "Faggot Jews" but you could probably guess where the real fascists would go with language like that. It plays right into the fantasy land of all-powerful liberals and conservative victim hood constructed by the right-wing where a barely noticed opinion piece from a free lance historian somehow equals all liberals calling for and immediately receiving whatever they wish for. The world does not work that way.

In case you read this Tim, I am not a blue falcon or any of the things you accused me of. I could care less if you or anyone else posts pictures of boobies. I have never reported anything to Facebook, nor do I know anyone who did. Facebook does not share my concern about political violence and I do not share their interest in making social media safe for elementary school kids. I do not care about sexy pics or off-color jokes or even the continuous outrage from certain members of that group. A group of which I am no longer a part of, by the way. After some reflection I realized that everything about it is a waste of my time. When I first joined, there was serious discussion between master gunners, interesting stories about our brothers' experiences in the field or on deployment, and general camaraderie. That is pretty rare to find now, and I'm tired of sifting through the garbage to find anything interesting. So thank you for convincing me to move on. I'm too old to find that Friday night grab-assing at the barracks style amusing anymore. And your since-
removed post with screen grabs of my writing just confirmed that I am correct in my concern over the potential for violence.

I have often felt annoyed that my service, in the opinion of people like you, did not count because we disagree on one thing or another. But by all means keep the crusade going. Being in a perpetual state of outraged and self-righteous victim hood is great for your heart and I hear it can even prevent ulcers.